Defensive Premo Poll

Started by no eye deer, April 20, 2016, 10:05:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

no eye deer

Gday FFFrs, simple poll for those of us looking to unload JJ and aren't going the DPP option. Already have Shaw and Laird.

Any comments/expert opinions most welcome, but hoping people will at least vote. Cheers, NED. ;)

supercoachhelp

Why did you leave out laird

no eye deer

Quote from: supercoachhelp on April 20, 2016, 10:06:25 PM
Why did you leave out laird

Ha! You got me as I was editing my post. Already have him and Shaw.

supercoachhelp


Grufflez

Rance>Docherty are going to dominate this poll.

no eye deer

Quote from: Grufflez on April 20, 2016, 10:11:38 PM
Rance>Docherty are going to dominate this poll.

Yeah that's what I was thinking. Just seeing if anyone can convince me otherwise. Biggs at his price could be worth a punt? I've decided I might double downgrade this week and hold JJ for a week, so whoever else I upgrade next week could decide how much I've got for a defender.

Samm79


ants

i like the look of docherty ! he seems to have overtaken simpson in the carlton defence ! getting better every year and i think he is a lot more consistant than rance but will average similar numbers

aces-high


Sabretooth Tigers

 :)

Both Rance and Docherty. Docherty has a great final 4 games and I'd get him 1st, then Rance.     ;)

enzedder

Rance. Glad I started with him but not so happy to share him.

backpocket

Trading JJ who would be the best option?

Jimmykidd

i assume you have laird? cause he'd be my pick.

out of those, probably docherty. good pod

GCSkiwi

Agree with Laird but Rance or Docherty if you already have Laird. Give Rance a slight edge over Docherty, but if you need a slighty cheaper option Doch's not bad. Wouldn't get Gibbo due to huge score inflating his average, wouldn't get Simmo as he's declining a little.

tommy10

What's Rance's % ownership?