Round 5 trades

[Jimmykidd]

Do I do

Papley to DBJ
Harwood to Ruggles/Byrne

or

Papley to DBJ
Lonergan to Ruggles/Byrne

Gotta be the first option. Hardwood eww

[Ricochet]

Do I do

Papley to DBJ
Harwood to Ruggles/Byrne

or

Papley to DBJ
Lonergan to Ruggles/Byrne

Harwood definitely has to go man

[WizzFizz]

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to Byrne/Ruggs

vs

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to hanners

dont know whether to upgrade now and gain extra points but then I will miss out on the cash that the defender rookies will make

[RoughRed]

Longeran + Sheridan => Gibson + DBJ???
75 + 75 vs 100+75 (AMT on field)
Backs then
Gibson, Bartell, MCkenzie, Weitering, Smith, AMT (Brown, DBJ) and Adams in fwds

Or

Sideways Lonergan (averging 74.5) to Fantasia (91.3)

27 trades left

[Asparagus]

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to Byrne/Ruggs

vs

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to hanners

dont know whether to upgrade now and gain extra points but then I will miss out on the cash that the defender rookies will make

THIS ^^^

You, me and around 10,000 others need this answered mate  ::)

[The Supercoach]

Does anyone know if Broad from the tigers will get a game soon or at all?

Was just going to leave him in my team (forgot trade him before rd 1) but was thinking i may as well get Ruggles in

[Ringo]

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to Byrne/Ruggs

vs

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to hanners

dont know whether to upgrade now and gain extra points but then I will miss out on the cash that the defender rookies will make

THIS ^^^

You, me and around 10,000 others need this answered mate  ::)

Purely subjective here and probably all wrong.
Double downgrade - Maybe having to play one one field at say 60 average means you are probably losing 40/50 popints over a premo. Maybe only 40/50 this week as next week you will be upgrading to a premo any way. You have built cash to allow the upgrade and both downgrades will be making $50/75k this week.

Premo Upgrade - Extra 40/50 points however majority of cash used and have to start looking for future opportunities.  Petracca will arrive soon and not sure whether Keays will start before Beams comes back to provide later downgrade options. 
Mason Cox may be included with Pies this week.

So as the saying goes bird in the hand so with 2 guaranteed cash rises from downgraded players more than likely will go the double downgrade track.

Papley to Byrne-Jones and Lonergan to Byrne.

Next week maybe deGoey to Dangerfield.  (One of the 44% who do not have him but hoping he drops a bit more)

But with the way my SC is this year suggest you do the opposite  ;)

[Goosey]

Thinking double downgrade too.

T.McKenzie > Byrne-Jones
B.Kennedy > Wagner via Kerridge to mids and Brown to fwds

Is Wagner a better option than Byrnes?

[Mat0369]

I'm thinking just the one. So it would be Papley to Byrne, Wagner or Byrne-Jones. I am leaning towards the last one.

[tommy10]

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to Byrne/Ruggs

vs

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to hanners

dont know whether to upgrade now and gain extra points but then I will miss out on the cash that the defender rookies will make

THIS ^^^

You, me and around 10,000 others need this answered mate  ::)

Problem is for me I have Lonergan in the mids with no def mid link up, so can only do double downgrade with Summner and DBJ/Ruggles/Byrne.

I have JJ so not sure to upgrade him to Selwood/Zaha/Sloane and move Lonergan to def or keep him in mids and trade JJ to Rance.

[kilbluff1985]

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to Byrne/Ruggs

vs

Lonergan to DBJ, papley to hanners

dont know whether to upgrade now and gain extra points but then I will miss out on the cash that the defender rookies will make

THIS ^^^

You, me and around 10,000 others need this answered mate  ::)

Problem is for me I have Lonergan in the mids with no def mid link up, so can only do double downgrade with Summner and DBJ/Ruggles/Byrne.

I have JJ so not sure to upgrade him to Selwood/Zaha/Sloane and move Lonergan to def or keep him in mids and trade JJ to Rance.

Lonergan out
sub a mid/fwd to mids
sub a def/fwd to forwards
trade in defender

[Bully]

Tempted to hold fire on Barlow this week and wait for Tom Rockliff next week, with a BE of 187 could shed as much as 40k. Maybe the double downgrade is the way to go and then upgrade Mills next week.

[Jake8]

Is trading Crouch to Ruggles and Papley to DBJ smart?

[Ringo]

Had a rethink after teams named and looking at Paps draw after this week reckon last week could have been an anomaly and he will bounce back and still make cash.  Even if he misses his 72 B/e will not fall much anyway.  Bigger upside imo than Milera.

So may Trades are Milera to Byrne Jones and still deciding on whether to go Lonergan to Birchall/Biggs or Lonergan to Ruggles/Byrne

[Bully]

Is trading Crouch to Ruggles and Papley to DBJ smart?

If Crouch was your M7 then doable, however bear in mind who you have to field this week.