Brodie Grundy

Started by krusty, April 16, 2016, 11:30:27 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

krusty

is he worth the risk? if not and why? which ruckman for the max price of $565100

Asparagus

Quote from: krusty on April 16, 2016, 11:30:27 AM
is he worth the risk? if not and why? which ruckman for the max price of $565100
NO

when he rests up forward he isn't much chop.
plus he does not seem to have progressed at all from last year.

Jimmykidd

Not worth the risk at all.

and gawn for that price range is best IMO.

krusty

anybody other than gawn?

GoLions

Quote from: krusty on April 16, 2016, 12:48:23 PM
anybody other than gawn?
You'd be mad not to get Gawn imo

jfitty

Wouldn't be picking any ruck not named Goldstein, Martin, Gawn, Naitanui or Blicavs

krusty

i have gawn, trying to fix a mistake i made in my rucks if i look at it the only other one in the price range is mummy unless i take a risk again

GoLions

Quote from: krusty on April 16, 2016, 01:00:49 PM
i have gawn, trying to fix a mistake i made in my rucks if i look at it the only other one in the price range is mummy unless i take a risk again
Ah ok, in that case I'd be trying to figure out how to get the extra cash for Goldy :P

krusty

ha ha unfortunately i cant find that extra cash do you think mummy will avg around what those guys will

GoLions

Quote from: krusty on April 16, 2016, 01:21:18 PM
ha ha unfortunately i cant find that extra cash do you think mummy will avg around what those guys will
Mummy or Jacobs would probably be your best bets, but Mummy is injury prone so fairly risky. Who are you trading?

Ringo

Seriously are you looking at getting rid of Gawn.  I am sure you must have more pressing issues with your team than him.  He will probably rise another 10k this week as well with a B/e of 75.

Unless rest of team is settled I would hold and for the record I have Goldy and Gawn as my rucks.

GoLions

Quote from: Ringo on April 16, 2016, 01:33:29 PM
Seriously are you looking at getting rid of Gawn.  I am sure you must have more pressing issues with your team than him.  He will probably rise another 10k this week as well with a B/e of 75.

Unless rest of team is settled I would hold and for the record I have Goldy and Gawn as my rucks.
Ringo pls. He has Gawn, and he's looking to bring in another ruck :P

Ringo

#12
Quote from: GoLions on April 16, 2016, 01:36:36 PM
Quote from: Ringo on April 16, 2016, 01:33:29 PM
Seriously are you looking at getting rid of Gawn.  I am sure you must have more pressing issues with your team than him.  He will probably rise another 10k this week as well with a B/e of 75.

Unless rest of team is settled I would hold and for the record I have Goldy and Gawn as my rucks.
Ringo pls. He has Gawn, and he's looking to bring in another ruck :P
Sorry misread it as gawn was his mistake sorry.

I would look at Jacobs or Blicavs to bring in then.

Mat0369

Mummy is going to go huge this week. They're playing Port meaning he is up against Lobbe. The risk obviously is his health but the scoring ability is there.

Jimmykidd

well your only option is mummy id say. not the worst pick i guess. just dont expext 22 games lol