Round 4 Team Announcements

[TomK]

Geelong play first thing Saturday so McCarthy is practically useless as emergency loophole

How do u work that out?
Emergency on menadue who plays Friday? Sub papley on for McCarthy if menadue scores poorly

Can't be any more suitable for a loophole

Some people have Menadue in the middle

[LF]

Geelong play first thing Saturday so McCarthy is practically useless as emergency loophole

How do u work that out?
Emergency on menadue who plays Friday? Sub papley on for McCarthy if menadue scores poorly

Can't be any more suitable for a loophole

Menadue is in my mids

[RaisyDaisy]

Maric is an emergency? WTF

[batt]

McCarthy rock solid job security they said ::)

If he plays in the VFL on Friday, then I'll be worried.

Otherwise, no alarm bells yet.

[Bully]

Maric is an emergency? WTF

Maric is toast, was lumbering around in the reserves last week like a dinosaur. Think you will find Hampson plays as our first ruck until form says otherwise, his last two weeks has been close to his best in Richmond colours.

[poolboybob]

McCarthy dropped, what is this shower

[Grufflez]

Devon Smith and WHE also ruled out

http://www.gwsgiants.com.au/news/2016-04-14/dual-injury-blow

Well shower not Devon
At least solves my who to field problem in BXV now

Any info on how serious Devon's knee complaint is?

[TomK]

Well we have Sumner playing his first game for the Blues this week, 123k fwd/mid, could be a good option in a couple weeks.

[mzunguman]

McCarthy rock solid job security they said ::)

If he plays in the VFL on Friday, then I'll be worried.

Otherwise, no alarm bells yet.

He's named on the HFF for tommorrows game.. Do we trade or hold?! that negative breakeven looks so good

[Grufflez]

Lincoln McCarthy omitted  :o

Surely they are just giving him a rest!

[fanTCfool]

Lincoln McCarthy omitted  :o

Surely they are just giving him a rest!

Agreed, he played his best game thus far against the Lions.
They're playing the bombers - I'm quite sure he's just being managed. Don't panic.

In other news that has seemed to have slipped under the radar - Pickett & Hopper are named on the extended bench but could easily get a run for the Giants on Sunday with many outs.

[jvalles69]

McCarthy rock solid job security they said ::)

Never thought the Scott brothers could be bigger White Goodmans than when they played...I was so wrong!  ::)

[Jimmykidd]

and trade mccarthy to who, exactly? ill be holding

[Rusty00]

In other news that has seemed to have slipped under the radar - Pickett & Hopper are named on the extended bench but could easily get a run for the Giants upon Sunday with many outs.

Darcy Tucker extended bench as well. Prob won't play but means he's getting closer.

In other news Barlow's on the extended bench........EVERYBODY PANIC :o :o :o

[batt]

He's named on the HFF for tommorrows game.. Do we trade or hold?! that negative breakeven looks so good

210% hold, he'll get games.

Don't expect him to line up