Seedsman to who

[kilbluff1985]

thinking about bailing on Seedsman who would you guys choose out of these 4

[Grufflez]

Smith or Docherty would be my vote out of those listed, you could always wait for a few others like Shaw to drop in price.
Bob Murphy out won't help JJ and the hawks showed what happens if you play a tighter game him.

[Raiden]

thinking about bailing on Seedsman who would you guys choose out of these 4

Has he been ruled out this week?

[kilbluff1985]

thinking about bailing on Seedsman who would you guys choose out of these 4

Has he been ruled out this week?

no but in doubt from the concussion and players are often quiet after them if they do play

[almonds]

didnt he finish of the game last week?

[Raiden]

Did he finish it? Good sign if he did, his been getting better & better. His score of 84 is servicable.

[RaisyDaisy]

Nah don't think he finished it

I really hope he plays this week, because I'm keeping him and dropping Lonergan instead (Plus need the extra cash from Lon)

[almonds]

Surely simpson is the best bet out of the 4 mentioned, still unsure whether JJ can keep it up

[Mat0369]

I prefer Simmo to Doc in SC but I think both are solid options. Doc has a habit of butchering the ball on occasions but he breaks lines and kicks it long. I think you had to start with Smith/JJ to make it worth it, I would flip a coin on one of the Carlton players.

[Holz]

I wouldnt trade out a guy priced at 340k who just pumped out 84 in 3/4 of football.

[Grazz]

Nah don't think he finished it

I really hope he plays this week, because I'm keeping him and dropping Lonergan instead (Plus need the extra cash from Lon)

9 news showed him training tonight and said he'd pulled up finel from a mild concussion. I say he's playing.

[RoughRed]

I wouldnt trade out a guy priced at 340k who just pumped out 84 in 3/4 of football.

+1
IMO  he is good value going forward, team is performing well, his role will develop, personally he still staying in my team then I do have good cover. Would not waste a trade!

[HotTiges]

bit of a hijack but is Lonergan worth downgrading to a rookie??

[ants]

will be keeping him for a few weeks yet!

[RaisyDaisy]

bit of a hijack but is Lonergan worth downgrading to a rookie??

I'm dumping him and keep The Seed