Which Premium defender

[sammy123]

current premo are Laird and Gibbo.

trading Murphy and these 4 are the best options IMO

[jvalles69]

Houli by a country Mile, but you need Shaw at some stage too.

[RaisyDaisy]

Houli by a country Mile, but you need Shaw at some stage too.

[Jimmykidd]

id be getting shaw first if you can afford him

[sammy123]

can't afford shaw at all

[jvalles69]

id be getting shaw first if you can afford him

Can wait a week on Shaw I think as he has a high BE, achievable, but shouldn't change his price too much, Houli has a low BE.

[sammy123]

id be getting shaw first if you can afford him

Can wait a week on Shaw I think as he has a high BE, achievable, but shouldn't change his price too much, Houli has a low BE.

could wait a week on shaw but playing MCtippa or brown scares me a bit

[jvalles69]

id be getting shaw first if you can afford him

Can wait a week on Shaw I think as he has a high BE, achievable, but shouldn't change his price too much, Houli has a low BE.

could wait a week on shaw but playing MCtippa or brown scares me a bit

Go for Houli now I think, Shaw still has a dud score in him to drop his price further. :P

[Ringo]

Yep I would grab Houli know as he probably will not get much cheaper whereas Shaw may come down a bit when he throws in his couple of low scores.

[ants]

Yep I would grab Houli know as he probably will not get much cheaper whereas Shaw may come down a bit when he throws in his couple of low scores.

Had houli last year and he was up and down like a yoyo! definately top 6 defender but shaw is less likely to give you dud scores and far more consistant and less likely come down in price than houli!

[Grufflez]

Rance is probably the safest bet.

[tor01doc]

2015
Scores of 70 or under

Houli 4
Rance 5

Shaw best
then Houli - esp this week if you want him

[sammy123]

gone with houli. and shaw could be in the team in a few weeks

[frenzy]

brodie smith

[Fid]

Houli by a country Mile, but you need Shaw at some stage too.