Round 4 Trades

[MC]

Hey guys, I posted this on the St Kilda board but not sure how soon i'll get a response. Perhaps someone here has some insight?

Hey boys, just wondering if you can fill me in on Dylan Roberton's role in the first three games thus far? Considering him for SC Draft (he was dropped in my league!). He seems to be racking up enough touches, have they been ineffective?

He's out for a few weeks injured, having to trade him out myself

Sorry mate, should have mentioned that. This would be as an investment to sit on my bench for a few weeks until he's back. If he's likely to provide a return of 90-odd i'm happy to wait for it!

[colmullet]

Hey guys, I posted this on the St Kilda board but not sure how soon i'll get a response. Perhaps someone here has some insight?

Hey boys, just wondering if you can fill me in on Dylan Roberton's role in the first three games thus far? Considering him for SC Draft (he was dropped in my league!). He seems to be racking up enough touches, have they been ineffective?

He's out for a few weeks injured, having to trade him out myself

Sorry mate, should have mentioned that. This would be as an investment to sit on my bench for a few weeks until he's back. If he's likely to provide a return of 90-odd i'm happy to wait for it!

Ahhh ok, i haven't noticed his role too much, but having him has been quite frustrating so far, definitely has potential but not to sure on him now as i was preseason

[Bones Bombers]

I want some more points on field so 2 trades this week.

Milera to Hartley or Ruggles.
Mills to Hall.

Need some help deciding between Hartley and Ruggles (I know its a week early) as I think I can only take 1. Wont be trading next week if I can help it.

Pick one?

[mark44]

You don't win SuperCoach sitting on your hands lol

Crouch to ruffles via two swings
Mills to Zorko who will swing forward later

Can go any mid up to 600k, should I go Zorko who will swing forward or should I go Selwood or Parker

Cheers

[Southstorm]

I want some more points on field so 2 trades this week.

Milera to Hartley or Ruggles.
Mills to Hall.

Need some help deciding between Hartley and Ruggles (I know its a week early) as I think I can only take 1. Wont be trading next week if I can help it.

Pick one?

Hartley has the JS you need, if not the scoring power you want.

[Ringo]

Not sure about Hartleys job security with Grimma coming back.   Ruggles should make you more cash given Scott has said should have been in since Rd 1 so suspect his JS is safe as well.  So I would go Ruggles.

[Bones Bombers]

I want some more points on field so 2 trades this week.

Milera to Hartley or Ruggles.
Mills to Hall.

Need some help deciding between Hartley and Ruggles (I know its a week early) as I think I can only take 1. Wont be trading next week if I can help it.

Pick one?

Hartley has the JS you need, if not the scoring power you want.

Cheers.
They will be on the bench. But scoring does mean price rises. Going to be a tough choice.

[kilbluff1985]

with 2 of my mid rookies not playing i'm considering jumping ship on Dea early for Hartley for extra cash i have 164k already so if i did this would be building a nice kitty

doubt i will do it just considering it might wait for Ruggles next week instead

[Bones Bombers]

Not sure about Hartleys job security with Grimma coming back.   Ruggles should make you more cash given Scott has said should have been in since Rd 1 so suspect his JS is safe as well.  So I would go Ruggles.

Cheers Ringo.
Have seen the Grima reports but I'd be very surprised if he takes a spot off Hartley. But you never know!
I'm probably more worried that he has been given the job on the number 1 forward. That will hurt his scoring.
Ruggles being a smaller running defender he would likely score better. Therefore I'm leaning towards him.

[RaisyDaisy]

with 2 of my mid rookies not playing i'm considering jumping ship on Dea early for Hartley for extra cash i have 164k already so if i did this would be building a nice kitty

doubt i will do it just considering it might wait for Ruggles next week instead

Yeah man don't trade Dea at all

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

Hi guys and gals, I started T McDonald as a sole defence keeper and Lonergan and Seedsman for their points and $ growth potential in the hope I'd pull two keepers out of the three. It appears as though Lonergan is being played as a run with tagger, Seeds maybe still picking up the Crows game plan but may be on the edge of coming good. But WTFH is the go with T McDonald ??  The only defenders I have ATM that may be keepers are both rookies, Adams and Weitering. Pretty strong everywhere else but absolutely stuffed here. Going to keep Seedsman for another three or four, Lonergan nearly the same, Bbut WHAT to do with T McDonald. Please any and all thoughts welcome.               :(

[MC]

:)

Hi guys and gals, I started T McDonald as a sole defence keeper and Lonergan and Seedsman for their points and $ growth potential in the hope I'd pull two keepers out of the three. It appears as though Lonergan is being played as a run with tagger, Seeds maybe still picking up the Crows game plan but may be on the edge of coming good. But WTFH is the go with T McDonald ??  The only defenders I have ATM that may be keepers are both rookies, Adams and Weitering. Pretty strong everywhere else but absolutely stuffed here. Going to keep Seedsman for another three or four, Lonergan nearly the same, Bbut WHAT to do with T McDonald. Please any and all thoughts welcome.               :(

TMAc is a KPP, in all likelihood, last season could have been an anomaly. I don't think you can carry all three of those blokes, i'd be looking to offload at least 1 while they hold currency.

TMac at 485k - Option might be Docherty for 2k or else KK for a few K less might be nice. If you have cash then a more proven prem would be the way to go.
Lonergan at 360k - Hasn't been too far off what we hoped for (85-90). I'd keep him for now.
Seedsman at 336k provides less options, probably worth a rookie downgrade.

[Keith Urban]

Longergan/Crouch -> Ruggles/Zorko

or

S.Gray/Crouch -> Ruggles/R.Gray

[vtaced]

What is everyone doing with Daniel 'Can't Break a Tag' Rich?

[Raiden]

What is everyone doing with Daniel 'Can't Break a Tag' Rich?

Giving him 1 more, if he doesn't score anywhere near a 80+ this week for the Qclash then his gone next week...