Round 4 Trades

[Grazz]

Thinking Gresham to Parish but not sure yet. Is it worth it? Gresham's JS is not that good as we thought at the start of the season.

wait for Petracca shouldn't be long

+1

[brudski]

Am i crazy for thinking
Crouch > Parker/Gray
Lonergan > Houli

I have plenty of cash in the bank to do both

They're not must do's but Lonergan (have him) is starting to look like a dud pick and Crouch (have him to "sigh") is going to be a slow to boil by the looks and missing games doesn't help. Those trades look solid if their your only concerns.

Im carrying seedsman and lonergan so i have to flick one of the two because they are costing me alot. Crouch if his out so early in the season warning bells are ringing. It is either de goey or crouch to parker or gray but de goey hasn't been to bad in a terrible pie's side so i think he will be a little bit better then crouch

[crowls]

lets see who gets selected rd 4,     hewett will be lucky, davis and menadue could also be gone.   fwds and backs probably ok.   


missed weitering, oliver will wait for petracca, freeman

[WizzFizz]

is it worth upgrading lonergan to a def premo or should I keep him for a bit

[MontyJnr]

is it worth upgrading lonergan to a def premo or should I keep him for a bit

He has Brisbane in the Q-Clash this week. One more chance I say.

[AaronKirk]

There are no must have rookies this week so I dunno about trades.

May just let the rookies moo another week and go from there but need to check BE's first.

[Grazz]

Am i crazy for thinking
Crouch > Parker/Gray
Lonergan > Houli

I have plenty of cash in the bank to do both

They're not must do's but Lonergan (have him) is starting to look like a dud pick and Crouch (have him to "sigh") is going to be a slow to boil by the looks and missing games doesn't help. Those trades look solid if their your only concerns.

Im carrying seedsman and lonergan so i have to flick one of the two because they are costing me alot. Crouch if his out so early in the season warning bells are ringing. It is either de goey or crouch to parker or gray but de goey hasn't been to bad in a terrible pie's side so i think he will be a little bit better then crouch

I understand your angst having both Seedsman and Longer down back. Seedsman was looking at a decent score till he went off for a concussion test, apart from rnd 1 he should of had two decent scores in rnd's 2 and 3 if not for the hit to the head yesterday which I missed, couldn't work out why his scoring had stopped. Longer got a run with role on Cripps which killed his score and not attending enough centre bounces for my liking now, my gut say's Eade has changed his role slightly and it's not transfering into points. He looks to be in all the right places to score but it's just not happening. To small a sample size to be confident in my choice but Lonergan may be the one to flick but if you can i'd hold off a couple more games until the answer is an obvious one. Can't say with any confidence which of those two should go.

[bartsy]

Sam Gray to Parker is my most likely trade. Is that a good en or do we think Sam can be the man we thought he could?

[dicko_]

If any rookies get dropped might do them to Hartley. Simply because he seems to have decent job security, perhaps better than any rookie who gets dropped, although that might not be the case since he didn't play round 1.

[jfitty]

Considering trading Mitch Brown down to Ruggles early so I can get rid of Leuy for a premo ruck

Would be 4 trades down but the rest of the team is looking pretty decent  ???

[barlowlove]

Have some cash in the bank (went Rocky to Pap), got 3 options this week
1. Gresham to Parker
2. Gresham to Hall, Pendles to Danger (crazy? i need Danger and Pendles looks like dropping off)
3. Gresham to Hall, keep $100k

:-\

[Cookie Monster]

Decided to pull the trigger on Matty Boyd and Matthew Lobbe this week, Boyd just not doing enough as a premium so traded him in for Burgoyne, almost put Johannison in but not too sure with Murphy out now.

With the cash from trading Rocky and Barlow out last week i was able to get Goldstein from Lobbe so now i think my team is set for the season.

Feeling very uneasy about Connor Menadue and George Hewett, feeling like they might get dropped this week. Especially Richmond will need some changes.

[Mat0369]

I am thinking holding is the way to go this week. Hartley will play on Tomahawk so I can't see him hitting his projected 70. He will jump 60k if he does but I don't think he is a must have. Ruggles I was keen on in the pre-season and he will be available next week, maybe one of Crouch, Brown or Menadue to Ruggles could be a go.

I plan on using Crouch as a loophole option if he misses again since Geelong play early and my only Friday night option is EMack

[tor01doc]

Getting worried with only 29 trades left so might just sit.

Only guy I would consider now is Fyfe. BE 104 ish

Oh and Hall.

[Grufflez]

None after r3 you are stuck with the bad premo selections.