Barlow or Rocky

[essendon33]

Pretty simple one which i think alot of us are facing at the moment, Barlow looks slow and as freo as a team do, and with 3 total centre bounce appearances his role seems to have changed, other hand rocky who is good for 100-110+ each week... when fit... which is a problem in itself.

Barlow - Hall & Gresham - BKen + 300k (Menadue to mids opening DPP, play BKen in fwd)
OR
Rocky - Hall & Gresham -BKen + 350k (Menadue to mids opening DPP, play BKen in fwd)
OR
Barlow - Hall & Rocky - Parker + 70k (Correction trades of 2 premos, missing out on the only value rookie i dont have)

Thoughts?

[ants]

Pretty simple one which i think alot of us are facing at the moment, Barlow looks slow and as freo as a team do, and with 3 total centre bounce appearances his role seems to have changed, other hand rocky who is good for 100-110+ each week... when fit... which is a problem in itself.

Barlow - Hall & Gresham - BKen + 300k (Menadue to mids opening DPP, play BKen in fwd)
OR
Rocky - Hall & Gresham -BKen + 350k (Menadue to mids opening DPP, play BKen in fwd)
OR
Barlow - Hall & Rocky - Parker + 70k (Correction trades of 2 premos, missing out on the only value rookie i dont have)

Thoughts?

option 2 > option 1> option 3! kennedy is a must ! if you dont have him!

[Grufflez]

Rocky out for 2 with the calf but how many weeks on return of sitting forward producing shower scores while he builds match fitness?
that could easily be 2 weeks out + 2-3 of crap scores, if i had to choose i'd roll the dice on Barlow, if he is dropped you know where the club stands, if he is named his slow butt will most likely play mid again.

I personally am dumping both when teams are named.

[fanTCfool]

Rockliff is injured, Barlow is not - so if you have to choose between the two I think that is your answer.

[bottlemart]

Option 2.  Trade out Rockliffe, hes injured.  Barlow is fit, had a great pre season and has just had 2 bad games.

[dmac07]

If you could trade both would you?

Thats my plan.