Barlow to Papley trade advice

[nathanjp24]

Hey guys just want to know which option i should do:

1. Barlow to Papley and Bartel to Johannisen

2. Rockliff to Papley and Bartel to JOhannisen

3. Petrecca to Papley and Barlow/Bartel side trade

4. Barlow to Papley and Petrecca upgrade

Or any other option using these players?

[Ricochet]

I'm holding Barlow,

But if you're keen to trade him how about just Barlow to Papley and hold Bartel?

[ants]

a think rockliff to papley and hold bartel and barlow!

[bottlemart]

a think rockliff to papley and hold bartel and barlow!

[Capper]

I think you are going a bit too cra cra for Papley.

After a slow start last year Barlow still was able to average 90+ so im holding him, rocky is out for a while so i will bench him.

The cats are playing Lions and Dogs playing the Hawks and you want to go Bartel to Johannisen? No champ!!

How many rookie fwds do you have? yes Paps will make you money but if you trade a prem for him then you are wasting 2 trades for $150k

[Asparagus]

I think you are going a bit too cra cra for Papley.

After a slow start last year Barlow still was able to average 90+ so im holding him, rocky is out for a while so i will bench him.

The cats are playing Lions and Dogs playing the Hawks and you want to go Bartel to Johannisen? No champ!!

How many rookie fwds do you have? yes Paps will make you money but if you trade a prem for him then you are wasting 2 trades for $150k

I am planning on doing this, it seems a bit more of a compromise-

Rocky to JJ via DPP with Rich (Rich ends up in midfield)...then Gresham to Papley via DPP with Bennedy, moving Bennedy into mids.

[SydneyRox]

I think you are going a bit too cra cra for Papley.

After a slow start last year Barlow still was able to average 90+ so im holding him, rocky is out for a while so i will bench him.

The cats are playing Lions and Dogs playing the Hawks and you want to go Bartel to Johannisen? No champ!!

How many rookie fwds do you have? yes Paps will make you money but if you trade a prem for him then you are wasting 2 trades for $150k

always the voice of reason when it comes to Swans!!

after watching him play in the nab cup, he was always a lock for me

i also agree trading barlow to paps not the best option. if you are trading barlow, it should be to another premium in better form

[tor01doc]

Hello SC sages

What do you think about this?

A team has Rocky, Barlow and Robbo and SIMPKIN but not Papley.

Plan is get Papley for Simpkin - simple?

Keeps the keepers.

Rocky not losing money yet.
Have faith in Robbo to stay a top 8 forward.
Barlow - wait and see.

Thoughts are appreciated

[jvalles69]

Hello SC sages

What do you think about this?

A team has Rocky, Barlow and Robbo and SIMPKIN but not Papley.

Plan is get Papley for Simpkin - simple?

Keeps the keepers.

Rocky not losing money yet.
Have faith in Robbo to stay a top 8 forward.
Barlow - wait and see.

Thoughts are appreciated

This is exactly what I've done, well the Simpkin to Papley part.  I'm trading Rocky too, don't trust a calf injury!

[Goosey]

Hello SC sages

What do you think about this?

A team has Rocky, Barlow and Robbo and SIMPKIN but not Papley.

Plan is get Papley for Simpkin - simple?

Keeps the keepers.

Rocky not losing money yet.
Have faith in Robbo to stay a top 8 forward.
Barlow - wait and see.

Thoughts are appreciated

This is exactly what I've done, well the Simpkin to Papley part.  I'm trading Rocky too, don't trust a calf injury!

Gresham to Papley for me.

[Ringo]

Hello SC sages

What do you think about this?

A team has Rocky, Barlow and Robbo and SIMPKIN but not Papley.

Plan is get Papley for Simpkin - simple?

Keeps the keepers.

Rocky not losing money yet.
Have faith in Robbo to stay a top 8 forward.
Barlow - wait and see.

Thoughts are appreciated

This is exactly what I've done, well the Simpkin to Papley part.  I'm trading Rocky too, don't trust a calf injury!

Gresham to Papley for me.

Gresham to Papley for me as well and Rocky to one of S Mitchell, T Mitchell or Parker.  Nerve issue with Rocky worries me. With a B/e 0f 184 he will most likely have a cash drop as well.  So we can see how he is when he comed back and decide whether to trade back in.

[Capper]

Rocky and JSteele out for me and PApley and GAJ in

[Capper]

I think you are going a bit too cra cra for Papley.

After a slow start last year Barlow still was able to average 90+ so im holding him, rocky is out for a while so i will bench him.

The cats are playing Lions and Dogs playing the Hawks and you want to go Bartel to Johannisen? No champ!!

How many rookie fwds do you have? yes Paps will make you money but if you trade a prem for him then you are wasting 2 trades for $150k

always the voice of reason when it comes to Swans!!

after watching him play in the nab cup, he was always a lock for me

i also agree trading barlow to paps not the best option. if you are trading barlow, it should be to another premium in better form

Had i had the time to properly look at teams before R1 i probably would have brought him in. The ball was in the fwd line a lot in R1 so hence why he scored so well.

Should have got him last week but wasnt sure he would get a 3rd game, but now know better.

[Goosey]

Hello SC sages

What do you think about this?

A team has Rocky, Barlow and Robbo and SIMPKIN but not Papley.

Plan is get Papley for Simpkin - simple?

Keeps the keepers.

Rocky not losing money yet.
Have faith in Robbo to stay a top 8 forward.
Barlow - wait and see.

Thoughts are appreciated

This is exactly what I've done, well the Simpkin to Papley part.  I'm trading Rocky too, don't trust a calf injury!

Gresham to Papley for me.

Gresham to Papley for me as well and Rocky to one of S Mitchell, T Mitchell or Parker.  Nerve issue with Rocky worries me. With a B/e 0f 184 he will most likely have a cash drop as well.  So we can see how he is when he comed back and decide whether to trade back in.

I can't decide on whether to trade Rocky to A.Hall or go straight for a premium in Parker or Gray etc. Bank some cash and take Hall or spend most of it on a keeper, will Hall be a keeper? In the forward line maybe?

[whynot102]

ROCKY TO LIBBA
BARLOW TO PAPLEY
BANK 600K
OR ROCKY TO LIBBA THEN MCKENZIE TRENT OR LONERGAN TO JJ
Thoughts