parker vs t.mitchell

Started by crawf-9, April 04, 2016, 05:59:23 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

crawf-9

want to trade in either parker or t.mitchell cant choose
thoughts anyone?

Capper

coin toss

What would you do with the $25k price difference?

Grufflez


crawf-9

saving my cash plus waiting for rookies to make cash to fix my stupid mistake of taking cheap rucks

crowls

both are good options.     cant separate their potential eoy, so toss a coin.  or just save the cash and take parker.

jfitty

It's hard to know which of Mitchell, Paker, Hannebery or JPK is worth owning at the moment..

Might let this one play out and grab a Sydney mid later in the season.

If I was picking right now though, I'd probably go Parker simply because he's cheaper.

Jimmykidd

tmitch for the pod factor. should avg the same as parker

Asparagus

I think this way..
Parker goes up forward more than Titch, to rest or grab a goal.
Titch I would say is the premium option.  ;)
Plus Parker scares me the way he goes so hard at it, injury chance.

Grufflez

Quote from: jfitty on April 05, 2016, 03:23:54 PM
It's hard to know which of Mitchell, Paker, Hannebery or JPK is worth owning at the moment..

Might let this one play out and grab a Sydney mid later in the season.

If I was picking right now though, I'd probably go Parker simply because he's cheaper.

I thought before the season started that JPK while still important to the team would be the one to drop off SC wise out of the 4, looking correct so far, i started Hanners assuming he and Mitchell would end up with the highest overall averages, i will probably get Tich in for Rocky
as he was the only player who never left my preseason team until i got a little concerned over his HB to Kick ratio, started him in DT though (Perma captain)

ants

Quote from: Grufflez on April 06, 2016, 12:52:44 PM
Quote from: jfitty on April 05, 2016, 03:23:54 PM
It's hard to know which of Mitchell, Paker, Hannebery or JPK is worth owning at the moment..

Might let this one play out and grab a Sydney mid later in the season.

If I was picking right now though, I'd probably go Parker simply because he's cheaper.

I thought before the season started that JPK while still important to the team would be the one to drop off SC wise out of the 4, looking correct so far, i started Hanners assuming he and Mitchell would end up with the highest overall averages, i will probably get Tich in for Rocky
as he was the only player who never left my preseason team until i got a little concerned over his HB to Kick ratio, started him in DT though (Perma captain)
what happens when sydney loses games! there are so many points that are getting shared between these players and its hard to pick the right ones! no sydney mids for me! they cant all be top mids come seasons end!

Grufflez

#10
Quote from: ants on April 06, 2016, 12:56:11 PM
Quote from: Grufflez on April 06, 2016, 12:52:44 PM
Quote from: jfitty on April 05, 2016, 03:23:54 PM
It's hard to know which of Mitchell, Paker, Hannebery or JPK is worth owning at the moment..

Might let this one play out and grab a Sydney mid later in the season.

If I was picking right now though, I'd probably go Parker simply because he's cheaper.

I thought before the season started that JPK while still important to the team would be the one to drop off SC wise out of the 4, looking correct so far, i started Hanners assuming he and Mitchell would end up with the highest overall averages, i will probably get Tich in for Rocky
as he was the only player who never left my preseason team until i got a little concerned over his HB to Kick ratio, started him in DT though (Perma captain)
what happens when sydney loses games! there are so many points that are getting shared between these players and its hard to pick the right ones! no sydney mids for me! they cant all be top mids come seasons end!

I actually think Hanners & Tich will be top 10 mids without injury and Parker just outside, with JPK around the 105 mark.
And Sydney is a top 4-5 team.

Ringo

Something to consider

Fantasy Freako ‏@FantasyFreako 1h1 hour ago

Centre bounce attendance numbers show that Parker has overtaken Hanners in there, attending 74% to his 37%. #SuperCoach #AFLFantasy

Will {Parker still attend the centre bounces when Sydney start to lose or will Hanners be thrown back in there.

Gandalf123

Quote from: Ringo on April 06, 2016, 01:27:16 PM
Something to consider

Fantasy Freako ‏@FantasyFreako 1h1 hour ago

Centre bounce attendance numbers show that Parker has overtaken Hanners in there, attending 74% to his 37%. #SuperCoach #AFLFantasy

Will {Parker still attend the centre bounces when Sydney start to lose or will Hanners be thrown back in there.

At the game sunday Hanners started most of the bounces out on the wing and looked good, don't expect that to change majorly, Parks, JPK and Jack are the better clearance workers anyway.

Grufflez

Quote from: Ringo on April 06, 2016, 01:27:16 PM
Something to consider

Fantasy Freako ‏@FantasyFreako 1h1 hour ago

Centre bounce attendance numbers show that Parker has overtaken Hanners in there, attending 74% to his 37%. #SuperCoach #AFLFantasy

Will {Parker still attend the centre bounces when Sydney start to lose or will Hanners be thrown back in there.

Very good point, they may prefer Parker and Mitchell extracting with Hanners playing a bit more outside. I now see why people are jumping on Parker, i had thought it was just a week by week team structural thing but those stats are pretty compelling, cheers.

My Chumps

Hanners has always started predominately on the wing. Never been a clearance player.