corrective trades

[jvalles69]

Would you trade Yeo > JJ and rocky > libba?

All rookies looking good, have papley, don't have Barlow, Bartel, rich or any of these other problem children. Have no issue with making a couple of correctives to make the team better. Silly not to pick libba up front but that's history. Do you think this makes sense?

I'd say you're in a good position and those 2 trades look good.

[ants]

Would you trade Yeo > JJ and rocky > libba?

All rookies looking good, have papley, don't have Barlow, Bartel, rich or any of these other problem children. Have no issue with making a couple of correctives to make the team better. Silly not to pick libba up front but that's history. Do you think this makes sense?

I'd say you're in a good position and those 2 trades look good.

+1

[dmac07]

My main two problems are Barlow and Rocky. Lucky/skilled enough to start with all the right rookies so dont need to get aby of them in. Don't have Libba though o thats the tough part of it.

Barlow abd Rocky to

1. Libba and Martin + 100k
2. Parker and Houli *via dpp
3. Libba and Fyfe *via dpp, lose my mid/fwd link.

Option 1 leaves cash to potentially dump Seedsman if he doesnt imrpove.

[Samm79]

My main two problems are Barlow and Rocky. Lucky/skilled enough to start with all the right rookies so dont need to get aby of them in. Don't have Libba though o thats the tough part of it.

Barlow abd Rocky to

1. Libba and Martin + 100k
2. Parker and Houli *via dpp
3. Libba and Fyfe *via dpp, lose my mid/fwd link.

Option 1 leaves cash to potentially dump Seedsman if he doesnt imrpove.

Like the first one mate

[ants]

My main two problems are Barlow and Rocky. Lucky/skilled enough to start with all the right rookies so dont need to get aby of them in. Don't have Libba though o thats the tough part of it.

Barlow abd Rocky to

1. Libba and Martin + 100k
2. Parker and Houli *via dpp
3. Libba and Fyfe *via dpp, lose my mid/fwd link.

Option 1 leaves cash to potentially dump Seedsman if he doesnt imrpove.

i would go rocky to libba and hold! but if barlow has to go i would go dusty! fyfe will drop in value this week!

[aces-high]

Thinking of going gresh to pap and de goey to Libba. Went unique and got graham instead of libba and feel now he's a must. De goey doesn't seem to be an integral part in the pies midfield and doesn't look like he's gonna price rise as high as I hoped. Pap looks a must and gresh is the stuff one to cull. It's either this or do the standard Barlow-johannison and rocky to Parker trade. I know this will boost points but i feel the other two trades balance my side better and give greater growth long term. Also can use rocky as a vc and if need be trade the others out next week. Thoughts?

[Ringo]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

[RoughRed]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

Gresham is going but my choices are Pap v BKennedy - have the cash
Player          Papley      Kennedy
Position        FWD         M/F
Cost            $109.9K     $187.8K
Project         107            66
BE              -147           -110
Plays           GWS           NM
Forecast R3  +113K       +$78K
Price R6      $400K        $310K

But this is based on Papley averaging 107 points for the next 4 games (GWS, ADE, WCE, BRI) and Kennedy only 63 (NM COL, RIC, StK)
What if per chance Papley only goes 70 and Kennedy 90 ????
I think Papley is facing the stronger teams
Can someone point me towards a calculator for this?
Not doubting Papley skill but i do prefer less simplistic analysis

[ants]

i wouldnt even look at projections as the people doing them are half wits especially when it comes to rookies! BK is the one you want if you only want one! without a doubt!

[plumdog millionaire]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

Same situation here - Got around 597k to play with. Reading around you like SMitchell and the Sydney mids, but Robbie Gray and Cal Ward are in the same discussion for mine.

The thing is, with most people having the top tier mids, picking the right POD-dy top 10 mids are important so I've got my eye on Titchell and Ward with sub 5% ownership and promising roles and history. Otherwise, Gray for certainty or even Ryen Griffen for a real POD

[Gigantor]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

If he maintains his current scoring he will be a keeper and not leaving my team:)

[Asparagus]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

Gresham is going but my choices are Pap v BKennedy - have the cash
Player          Papley      Kennedy
Position        FWD         M/F
Cost            $109.9K     $187.8K
Project         107            66
BE              -147           -110
Plays           GWS           NM
Forecast R3  +113K       +$78K
Price R6      $400K        $310K

But this is based on Papley averaging 107 points for the next 4 games (GWS, ADE, WCE, BRI) and Kennedy only 63 (NM COL, RIC, StK)
What if per chance Papley only goes 70 and Kennedy 90 ????
I think Papley is facing the stronger teams
Can someone point me towards a calculator for this?
Not doubting Papley skill but i do prefer less simplistic analysis

I am just a little nervous that the Swans will drop/rest/rotate some of the rookies as they tire/drop off.

With BK there is much less risk of that as he is a ready made senior player. He may get dropped because of form but he will not tire.

[SC_Dave]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

Gresham is going but my choices are Pap v BKennedy - have the cash
Player          Papley      Kennedy
Position        FWD         M/F
Cost            $109.9K     $187.8K
Project         107            66
BE              -147           -110
Plays           GWS           NM
Forecast R3  +113K       +$78K
Price R6      $400K        $310K

But this is based on Papley averaging 107 points for the next 4 games (GWS, ADE, WCE, BRI) and Kennedy only 63 (NM COL, RIC, StK)
What if per chance Papley only goes 70 and Kennedy 90 ????
I think Papley is facing the stronger teams
Can someone point me towards a calculator for this?
Not doubting Papley skill but i do prefer less simplistic analysis

There is an accurate salary calculator on  tooserious.net, and also a feature to upload and track your team.
I've been using it for years and it's great.

[ants]

Like you I think Pap is a must as he is predicted to rise $113k this week so you need to be on that train.  If He maintains current scoring he could be around $400k by round 6 allowing a nice down grade to Petracca and and upgrade,

I am doing gresh to papley as well but then Rocky to ??.  Really concerned with nerve related injuries.

Gresham is going but my choices are Pap v BKennedy - have the cash
Player          Papley      Kennedy
Position        FWD         M/F
Cost            $109.9K     $187.8K
Project         107            66
BE              -147           -110
Plays           GWS           NM
Forecast R3  +113K       +$78K
Price R6      $400K        $310K

But this is based on Papley averaging 107 points for the next 4 games (GWS, ADE, WCE, BRI) and Kennedy only 63 (NM COL, RIC, StK)
What if per chance Papley only goes 70 and Kennedy 90 ????
I think Papley is facing the stronger teams
Can someone point me towards a calculator for this?
Not doubting Papley skill but i do prefer less simplistic analysis

There is an accurate salary calculator on  tooserious.net, and also a feature to upload and track your team.
I've been using it for years and it's great.

yea i use it too! but papley isnt going to average over 100 over the next three games! and thats what it is based on so no!!!!

[Jimmykidd]

I missed out on Papsmear and Libba.

Rocky > Libba
Barlow > Paps

Risky I know, but it leaves me with 760k in the bank. Can make a few upgrades in a few weeks.

Thoughts?