Best mid under $570k need help choosing

Started by bartsy, March 23, 2016, 03:47:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Marstar

Quote from: batt on March 23, 2016, 05:02:23 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 23, 2016, 04:27:58 PM
No way Shiel is in the same league as Selwood, in fact I place Sidebottom and Ward ahead of him. Shiel had two scores of 50 odd last year, I watched one of the games where he was completely blanketed, I'm just not confident he can handle a tag. He's also coming back from injury and we don't know how Treloar's absence will hamper his progress. Fine to put on the watchlist but there are better options.
He had 3 50 odd scores last year, two of which were injury affected.  The third was the one you must have watched (I did too, I owned him) and Jacobs tore him a new one. 

Treloar's absence doesnt mean much IMO, GWS have too much talent for their own good and Treloar was rarely closely played.

Jacobs did what Crowly, Carrazzo and many others failed to do on Rocky in 2014.

Shiels has the high ceiling to compensate.

Selwood,  Ward,  Shiel, Tichell for me.

Bully

Quote from: batt on March 23, 2016, 05:02:23 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 23, 2016, 04:27:58 PM
No way Shiel is in the same league as Selwood, in fact I place Sidebottom and Ward ahead of him. Shiel had two scores of 50 odd last year, I watched one of the games where he was completely blanketed, I'm just not confident he can handle a tag. He's also coming back from injury and we don't know how Treloar's absence will hamper his progress. Fine to put on the watchlist but there are better options.
He had 3 50 odd scores last year, two of which were injury affected.  The third was the one you must have watched (I did too, I owned him) and Jacobs tore him a new one. 

Treloar's absence doesnt mean much IMO, GWS have too much talent for their own good and Treloar was rarely closely played.

No it was the Swans game, no injury to speak of. Shiel struggles with the attention, not sold by any stretch of the imagination.


Holz


batt

Quote from: Bully on March 23, 2016, 06:16:42 PM
No it was the Swans game, no injury to speak of. Shiel struggles with the attention, not sold by any stretch of the imagination.
No injury to speak of, except for an ankle injury in the 3rd quarter.

Bully

Quote from: batt on March 24, 2016, 05:43:05 PM
Quote from: Bully on March 23, 2016, 06:16:42 PM
No it was the Swans game, no injury to speak of. Shiel struggles with the attention, not sold by any stretch of the imagination.
No injury to speak of, except for an ankle injury in the 3rd quarter.

"The Swans did their homework on their cross town rivals as Craig Bird did another shut down job, this time on the Giants best player from the first two rounds Dylan Shiel. The GWS skilful runner averaged 27 disposals and two goals in the first two matches but could manage just 15 while Bird finished with 22."

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/2015-afl-season-sydney-defeats-gws-giants-by-21-points-at-scg-in-round-3/news-story/1733e04ea174e074895f204e2b669788