Mills vs Oliver vs Parish?

Started by Woppa15, March 17, 2016, 09:41:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Woppa15

Firstly, if you had to choose one which would it be?
Secondly, could you feasably fit all 3 in?

shaker

Mills at this stage purely like a lot of other people because there are not enough cheapies looking likely  :'(

GCSkiwi

Isn't Parish injured? I've basically totally wiped him out of contention to be honest, did well in NAB1 but not sure how excited I would be about him without seeing something more - if he's named round 1 I'd still give him a couple of weeks to see and then corrective trade if he kills it, at this point I wouldn't be going near him. I have both Mills and Oliver though.

jfitty

Don't think I'd be picking Parish, and Mills over Oliver for me (although having both of them is feasible).

Anyone looking at Macaffer? His scoring potential might not be as good, but JS could be better than some of these rookies?

Gigantor

I would pick Crowley over Parish

GoLions

I can't split Mills and Oliver atm. Definitely not starting Parish though.

Big Mac


quinny88

Only got to see Parish once which has put me off

aarontays

Currently have both Mills and Oliver. With the limited amount of mid rookies most teams will have to have a few of these 200k+ rookies. Not a fan of Parish but that's just my opinion. If i had to pick one i would probably go Oliver over Mills tbh. Think his more SC friendly playing at the Demons.

jvalles69

Anyone considering Macaffer or Crowley over these 2 or 1?  Both save 10-40K and could very well score the same.  I think Mills will be the top scorer of the group, but hard to split Crowley/Oliver/Caff dependent on role.

Blues Blues Blues

I currently have both Mills and Oliver. I've had to move from a 5 premo mid to 4, plus Libba and Crouch. I think Mills and Oliver at M7 and M8 should score well, plus allows me to bring Shaw into defense and Buddy to F3.