Any good ?? Top 2000 last year

[Sicko]

Here is my line up so far:

FWD:  KK, Jimmy Bartel, E.Yeo, B.Smith, M.Brown, K.Collins (D.Tucker, N.Broad)
MID:  Fyfe, Pendles, Ablett, Rocky, Wines, Libba, S.Kerridge, R.Mathieson (R.Clarke, J.Dunkley, A.Marcon)
RUCK:  Goldy, Martin (S.Grimely)
FWD:  Martin, Dahlhaus, Barlow, Wells, C.Petracca, N.Kommer (T.Read, A.McDonadl-Tipa)


And got $7 800 in the bank.

Any feedback is welcome!

[Discomaniac]

B.Crouch in backline??

Obviously your defence is the weakest and riskiest. As far as keepers go KK, Bartel and yeo are pretty light but may pay off. I'm not sold on yeo with two underwhelming NAB cup performances. Rookies are ok but T.Read should be replaced with Cox from pies as he has more chance of getting a game.

[Sicko]

My bad, I meant B.Smith not B.Crouch haha.

However would this be an improvement on the backline ?
Trade B.Smith for T.Sheridan and then Yeo for Laird. Leaving me with:

Laird, KK, Jimmy Bartel, T Sheridan, M.Brown, K.Collins (D.Tucker, N.Broad)

[MC]

My bad, I meant B.Smith not B.Crouch haha.

However would this be an improvement on the backline ?
Trade B.Smith for T.Sheridan and then Yeo for Laird. Leaving me with:

Laird, KK, Jimmy Bartel, T Sheridan, M.Brown, K.Collins (D.Tucker, N.Broad)

Yes that's a good trade.

[ronl]

I'm a big fan of KK and thought he would be ready, but there's something wrong, probably an injury of some sort.  I'd hold off on him until we find out what's going on.  Also, most of the top teams have already worked Dangerfield into their mids.  He would be a "must have" to replace Wines.

[Sicko]

UPDATED TEAM:  Better or Worse???

FWD:  Laird, KK, Jimmy Bartel, M.Brown, N.Broad, M.Adams (K.Collins, M.Hartley)
MID:  Fyfe, Pendles, Ablett, Rocky, Wines, Libba, C.Mills, B.Kennedy (J. Gresham, C.Petracca, R.Clarke)
RUCK:  Goldy, Martin (M.Cox)
FWD:  Martin, Dahlhaus, Barlow, Wells, C.Menaude, S.Kerridge (A.McDonadl-Tip, N.Kommer)


Again, any feedback is appreciated

[Skilts14]

I like the team, Bartel to houli somehow would be good. Maybe dahlhaus downgraded to Greene. Just done thoughts. Love goldy Martin ruck combo.