2016 NAB Challenge: Bulldogs v Melbourne -Sunday 6th march 2:05-Highgate Reserve

Started by LF, March 02, 2016, 02:21:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

quinny88

Quote from: nrich102 on March 06, 2016, 05:20:27 PM
Minson needs to retire. Just 7 HO's today, half of what Campbell did and they were both monstered by Gawn.

I assumed he wasn't playing in the ruck? Didn't see the game but he usually puts up big hit out numbers when playing in the ruck

Ringo

SC Scores

BULLDOGS

Lin Jong 115

Tom Liberatore 107

Josh Dunkley 94

Mitch Honeychurch 89

Jordan Roughead 82

Caleb Daniel 79

Nathan Hrovat 76

Marcus Adams 76

Will Minson 69

Josh Prudden 68

Jed Adcock 63

Kieran Collins 62

Jack Redpath 61

Lukas Webb 61

Tom Boyd 59

Zaine Cordy 58

Tom Campbell 56

Bailey Dale 56

Toby McLean 52

Brad Lynch 51

Joel Hamling 46

Bailey Williams 42

Fletcher Roberts 35

Declan Hamilton 13

Luke Goetz 5

MELBOURNE

Jack Viney 113

Max Gawn 112

Nathan Jones 103

Matt Jones 96

Dom Tyson 92

Tom McDonald 92

James Harmes 90

Jack Watts 89

Bernie Vince 81

Jeff Garlett 79

Christian Salem 78

Ben Kennedy 76

Jack Grimes 74

Tomas Bugg 74

Clayton Oliver 70

Aaron Vandenberg 66

Neville Jetta 63

Cameron Pedersen 61

Jayden Hunt 40

Sam Frost 36

Dean Kent 32

Lynden Dunn 30

Josh Wagner 27

Viv Michie 27

Colin Garland 23

Billy Stretch 0

Libba if not locked already should be with key thrown away.

quinny88

Very nice from Dunkley.
Collins solid again and Adams creates another option.

LordSneeze

Quote from: quinny88 on March 06, 2016, 08:50:07 PM
Very nice from Dunkley.
Collins solid again and Adams creates another option.

I think only 1 of Collins or Adams will play R1, both paly fairly similar roles. A lot of people will just look at the stats which show Collins having more possessions and points, but to me Adams has been the better performing over both games and probably just ahead of Collins at the moment.
Dunkley would have to be a lock if named. Looked hungry and composed. How much will the guns coming back hurt him though? At 117k it shouldn't matter.

Gawn didn't do enough for me against a weak ruck setup.
Mcdonald had a poor kicking game, should was still able to go 90+. If he kicked slightly better he would have got 110+
Oliver shows glipses, but difficult to pick at 207k as not likely to go 80+
Bugg. 71% TOG. Only went at 64% DE. Very tempted to have him as my breakout pick.
Kennedy didn't' have a great game, but still locked into my forward line.