Player Vs Player

[Jalapeno]

Franklin vs dusty. Franklin in as good as form as he has been in dusty no so good but if Richmond fire up a bit so could he, both around same price but very different players, who's the pick of em.

I would 99.9% of the time say Dusty because of his role, yet Buddy looks the goods this year so its a 50/50. Would lean towards Dusty though, just.

[Jalapeno]

I need a few evaluations please:

Nroo vs Goldstein

Montags vs Buddy/Dusty

Thanks all

[Koop]

I need a few evaluations please:

Nroo vs Goldstein

Montags vs Buddy/Dusty

Thanks all

Nroo breaking down/slowing down is always in the back of my mind, but there's plenty of worse options around, especially in the form he is in. You know what you're going to get with Goldstein, depends on structure really.

Id say Montagna purely because 2013 Dusty still gives me nightmares and I havent selected him since, but thats a biased opinion.

Mullett vs Trengove for a DEF downgrade this week?

Zorko vs Dahl as well.

[Huttabito]

DEF downgrade to avoid a donut.

Mohr v Brand?

[Rusty00]

Rocky vs Ablett - as in which one would you keep and which one to trade.

Was willing to sit Rocky on the bench until he returned and upgrade other areas, but with all the carnage this week I think I'm going to have to trade one of these two :-\

[WhatMate]

Rocky vs Ablett - as in which one would you keep and which one to trade.

Was willing to sit Rocky on the bench until he returned and upgrade other areas, but with all the carnage this week I think I'm going to have to trade one of these two :-\

“Tom’s going really well in his rehab and it’s progressing as we expect it should. He’s running well and he should start training with the main group this week.

http://www.lions.com.au/news/2016-05-17/recovery-report

I guess maybe you could go by this and take the chance that Ablett is more likely to be back next week? Plus Rockys BE will be higher so if he does come good he'll drop in price again?

[Rusty00]

Rocky vs Ablett - as in which one would you keep and which one to trade.

Was willing to sit Rocky on the bench until he returned and upgrade other areas, but with all the carnage this week I think I'm going to have to trade one of these two :-\

“Tom’s going really well in his rehab and it’s progressing as we expect it should. He’s running well and he should start training with the main group this week.

http://www.lions.com.au/news/2016-05-17/recovery-report

I guess maybe you could go by this and take the chance that Ablett is more likely to be back next week? Plus Rockys BE will be higher so if he does come good he'll drop in price again?

Good point on BEs.

However given I now only 3 forwards named I probably need to focus my trades there ;) :'(

[WhatMate]

Rocky vs Ablett - as in which one would you keep and which one to trade.

Was willing to sit Rocky on the bench until he returned and upgrade other areas, but with all the carnage this week I think I'm going to have to trade one of these two :-\

“Tom’s going really well in his rehab and it’s progressing as we expect it should. He’s running well and he should start training with the main group this week.

http://www.lions.com.au/news/2016-05-17/recovery-report

I guess maybe you could go by this and take the chance that Ablett is more likely to be back next week? Plus Rockys BE will be higher so if he does come good he'll drop in price again?

Good point on BEs.

However given I now only 3 forwards named I probably need to focus my trades there ;) :'(

No DPP options?

[WhatMate]

Not sure who to get rid of..
Papley (Not sure of extent of injury), Gaz (should be back next week?), Wells (Chance for next week but pre-existing injury), Barlow (39 Possies last week in reserves, but who knows what Lyon is thinking), Hall (should be back next week?)

Currently leaning towards Wells or Barlow I guess.. Papley still has room to earn cash although might have trouble finding his way back into the team, although willing to hold him for now. Barlow isnt injured but no idea when he could be back. Wells well Ive loved his work this year but maybe its time to get rid of him and not risk having him on the pine for another week?

Could Gaz and Hall get another week?

ughhh decisions... any insight of info or thoughts would be appreciated.. Thinking Walters is the upgrade target at this point

[DBRiMatt]

Keeping hall, gaz i I have decided to trade

barlow... keeping for now... but if he misses another 1 i'll switch

[Nails]

Coniglio
vs
Viney
vs
Hannerbry
vs
Merrett

[WhatMate]

Coniglio
vs
Viney
vs
Hannerbry
vs
Merrett

Hannerby is most proven
Coniglio is best for Pod status

[WhatMate]

Who to get rid of
Wells, Barlow or Ablett

[Nails]

Who to get rid of
Wells, Barlow or Ablett

Hold all 3 if you can

If you have to get rid of one: Ablett

[WhatMate]

Who to get rid of
Wells, Barlow or Ablett

Hold all 3 if you can

If you have to get rid of one: Ablett

Why Ablett though? That's what im trying to get my head around, cant find a reason If you get me?
Have to get rid of one to avoid a dounut and also get Walters in