Is Aaron hall a good/stupid pick for FWD 4 or 5?

[Marstar]

Does he become a bit more relevant with Swallow and JOM missing early games?

I think Touk is the big winner, sitting just under the radar.

@ $394k?? What do you expect him to avg??

Yeah, sorry, wasn't implying SC relevance ... just feel he's going to benefit most from their absence.

[sammy123]

have considered hall. just don't want him to score beautifully then drop off when prestia,JOM etc return and he gets pushed as a small fwd

[TomK]

Fantasy Freako ‏@FantasyFreako  1h1 hour ago
Aaron Hall has started in 89% of all centre bounces - the highest % of any player in the #NABChallenge. #SuperCoach #AFLFantasy

[batt]

I think his pace is a real weapon to the Suns midfield and I can see him playing there even when the guns come back.

At least that's what I'm hoping for. 

[sammy123]

i feel he will be a start with or jump on early guy.  will be a nice F7,8 comes year end

[Ringo]

One thing to remember though is Hall has only played one full season in 2013 and 16 and 15 in 2014 and 15 so need to factor missing games in.  Very awkwardly priced and will he be the one to make way when guns come back.  Will not make that much cash either if you have to trade out.

[ben_020285]

One thing to remember though is Hall has only played one full season in 2013 and 16 and 15 in 2014 and 15 so need to factor missing games in.  Very awkwardly priced and will he be the one to make way when guns come back.  Will not make that much cash either if you have to trade out.

Disagree. I don't think he will be the one to make way when the guns come back. Perhaps he will have less minutes in the midfield but he will still play in the guts a lot. I see him as the logical Bennell replacement.

[Mat0369]

Disagree. I don't think he will be the one to make way when the guns come back. Perhaps he will have less minutes in the midfield but he will still play in the guts a lot. I see him as the logical Bennell replacement.

I think the guy that was given Harley's number is going to be his replacement in the midfield rotation, that would be Touk Miller.

[eaglesman]

Disagree. I don't think he will be the one to make way when the guns come back. Perhaps he will have less minutes in the midfield but he will still play in the guts a lot. I see him as the logical Bennell replacement.

I think the guy that was given Harley's number is going to be his replacement in the midfield rotation, that would be Touk Miller.

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

[RaisyDaisy]

Disagree. I don't think he will be the one to make way when the guns come back. Perhaps he will have less minutes in the midfield but he will still play in the guts a lot. I see him as the logical Bennell replacement.

I think the guy that was given Harley's number is going to be his replacement in the midfield rotation, that would be Touk Miller.

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

Does it really matter?

I'm not picking him personally,  but I can see the appeal. Going light in the forwards so he's not even a consideration, and although he could be a decent F4/5 I don't think that's the right structure this year

[ben_020285]

Disagree. I don't think he will be the one to make way when the guns come back. Perhaps he will have less minutes in the midfield but he will still play in the guts a lot. I see him as the logical Bennell replacement.

I think the guy that was given Harley's number is going to be his replacement in the midfield rotation, that would be Touk Miller.

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

Yep, I've been considering him well before the NAB Challenge.

I'm pretty sure I'll end up picking either Hall or Greene at F3.

[Mat0369]

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

I have 0 interest. He is fringe in the 22, even though he was playing as a half forward most of his career he doesn't have elite speed, he doesn't have super endurance and with less rotations that will hinder him. Add in the fact he is probably their 10th best midfielder and has hit the ton 5 times in his career, most of those came when the Suns were missing half their team why would you bother at 420k? 

[Southstorm]

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

I have 0 interest. He is fringe in the 22, even though he was playing as a half forward most of his career he doesn't have elite speed, he doesn't have super endurance and with less rotations that will hinder him. Add in the fact he is probably their 10th best midfielder and has hit the ton 5 times in his career, most of those came when the Suns were missing half their team why would you bother at 420k?

enough said

[ben_020285]

You lads considering hall as an option? Or just joining in this thread's convo

I have 0 interest. He is fringe in the 22, even though he was playing as a half forward most of his career he doesn't have elite speed, he doesn't have super endurance and with less rotations that will hinder him. Add in the fact he is probably their 10th best midfielder and has hit the ton 5 times in his career, most of those came when the Suns were missing half their team why would you bother at 420k?

This is why fantasy footy is great. You have zero interest and I am very interested. Right now neither of us truly know whether he will be a good pick or not.

Lots of people are all over Aish but I don't see the appeal but that's ok because there's no wrong or right but just opinions based on our own knowledge and views.

[Mat0369]

This is why fantasy footy is great. You have zero interest and I am very interested. Right now neither of us truly know whether he will be a good pick or not.

Lots of people are all over Aish but I don't see the appeal but that's ok because there's no wrong or right but just opinions based on our own knowledge and views.

When SC opened I liked the fact I could grab Aish as a defender, after thinking about it I figure he will go 75 at best and could get Crouch for about 30k more. I haven't bothered with him since.