Is Aaron hall a good/stupid pick for FWD 4 or 5?

[jvalles69]

If you didn't stat with GOLDY I feel bad for you son, I got 99 SC problems, but A ruck ain't one!  :D

Fixed that for ya! ;D

That works, I got Goldy too!  ;D

[Ringo]

I did not start with him but plaudits to those that did.

I will not be getting him in now as I think his price may peak and really do not want to chase last weeks points. Really want to see how he goes in against the heavy weights over the rounds to byes. Play Brisbane at Gabba (where I will be watching him closely), Geelong at Simmonds, Melbourne at Metricon, Giants at Spotless, Crows at Metricon, Eagles at Domain and Swans at Metricon.  If he scores solidly then I will look at bringing him in and we will also know what impact Swallow and O'Meara will have on him.  Also have the concern that Rocket has said Jack Martin will probably get more mid time as he gets match fit.

So in summary congrats to those that selected in from Rd 1 but I am not convinced I should trade him in now so waiting to judge on performances against quality opposition. (Bombers, a Feo rabble and Blues do not constitute quality opposition sorry).

[sammy123]

i think he can maintain it. after watching him against carlton kid just seemed to be everywhere. interviewed after game. said he wants to be a mid only. so diring pre season he worked on fitness etc. i think he can stay there for the whole season if he keeps getting the ball

[MontyJnr]

I did not start with him but plaudits to those that did.

I will not be getting him in now as I think his price may peak and really do not want to chase last weeks points. Really want to see how he goes in against the heavy weights over the rounds to byes. Play Brisbane at Gabba (where I will be watching him closely), Geelong at Simmonds, Melbourne at Metricon, Giants at Spotless, Crows at Metricon, Eagles at Domain and Swans at Metricon.  If he scores solidly then I will look at bringing him in and we will also know what impact Swallow and O'Meara will have on him.  Also have the concern that Rocket has said Jack Martin will probably get more mid time as he gets match fit.

So in summary congrats to those that selected in from Rd 1 but I am not convinced I should trade him in now so waiting to judge on performances against quality opposition. (Bombers, a Feo rabble and Blues do not constitute quality opposition sorry).

So he might drop from a 130 average to a 100 average. I can deal with that.

He is Ablett's best mate. Ablett looks to get him involved whenever possible.

[sammy123]

I did not start with him but plaudits to those that did.

I will not be getting him in now as I think his price may peak and really do not want to chase last weeks points. Really want to see how he goes in against the heavy weights over the rounds to byes. Play Brisbane at Gabba (where I will be watching him closely), Geelong at Simmonds, Melbourne at Metricon, Giants at Spotless, Crows at Metricon, Eagles at Domain and Swans at Metricon.  If he scores solidly then I will look at bringing him in and we will also know what impact Swallow and O'Meara will have on him.  Also have the concern that Rocket has said Jack Martin will probably get more mid time as he gets match fit.

So in summary congrats to those that selected in from Rd 1 but I am not convinced I should trade him in now so waiting to judge on performances against quality opposition. (Bombers, a Feo rabble and Blues do not constitute quality opposition sorry).

looking at those teams. should score well against Brisbane, Melbourne, Giants,

geelong sydney eagles and adelaide he could still score 70-100 which isn't bad if he is closer to 100

[AaronKirk]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

[Holz]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Luke Parker?

[dmac07]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Got on him at 100s last week. Now 35s. Unlikely but worth a shot.

[AaronKirk]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Luke Parker?

Parker is in a tie for 2nd with 6 votes.

[no eye deer]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Luke Parker?

Parker is in a tie for 2nd with 6 votes.

With Danger. My money's on him. Didn't get 100/1 though!

[aussied]

going to make a trade to either Hall or Parker. Hall is cheaper but i feel Parker is way more secure.... anyone think its worth it bringing in hall over parker to save the 100k?

[tor01doc]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Luke Parker?

Parker is in a tie for 2nd with 6 votes.

With Danger. My money's on him. Didn't get 100/1 though!

Smitch might get his second Charlie

[Jay]

going to make a trade to either Hall or Parker. Hall is cheaper but i feel Parker is way more secure.... anyone think its worth it bringing in hall over parker to save the 100k?

I'm considering bringing in Hall this week.

[AaronKirk]

Keep in mind for later in the year for a bet for who leads the brownlow after 5 Rounds.

I have him 2 votes clear on top at the moment.

Luke Parker?

Parker is in a tie for 2nd with 6 votes.

With Danger. My money's on him. Didn't get 100/1 though!

Smitch might get his second Charlie

He is right up there doc.

[NickyBoy]

Is Hall the real deal? 3 tons but would I just be trying to chase points if I trade him in now? Not too many cheap options in the forward line which isn't helping  >:(