Give me a rate please!!!

[aden111]

Defenders: H.Shaw, K.Kolodjashnij, B.Smith, J.Adock, J.Wagner, R.Bonner (M.Adams, M.Hartley)

Mids: G.Ablett,A.Treloar, M.Bontempelli, D.Shiel, T.Rockliff, T.Liberatore, J.Polec, C.Petrecca (D.Gore, R.Mathesion, J.Dunkley)

Rucs: M.Blicavs, M.Lobbe (M.Cox)

Forwards: H.Bennell, D.Zorko, T.Walker, D.Sheed, B.Kennedy, S.Kerridge (N.Cockatoo, M.Brown)

[JMAN23]

if someone could help out my friend that would be really nice as his new to supercoach! Go aden111

[FactHunt]

Back line is strong. Keep an eye on my mob (Bombers) as we lost a few through suspension... i like Brown in def over fwd as i think there will be more options here (but NAB will tell).

Mids are interesting- some risk (PODS) in Treloar, Bont, Shiel... I would tend to take one, or even two of these at most and go with proven players who you are more confident will finish top 8 mid scorers by years end- that being said, with risk comes reward and if you think all three can finish in top 8 mids then you are two steps ahead of the rest of us.

Rucks line I'm not excited about. But mostly speculation- Blic has been flagged for less time in the Ruc, he's a supreme athlete and may be suited by the elimination of the sub rule/reduced rotations- I just don't like the queries (again, time will tell). And Lobbe has his upside, but my main concern in this line is that I feel neither will finish top three in the Ruc line... meaning trades, trades, trades to get this line right come season's end. (again, if you feel that either or both these guys can finish top three, keep one or both).

Forward is a bit scary too. These 'premiums' are all risky, as all OR none could finish top six in this line for the year. There's plenty of mid-price options up forward that i think are great this year (hence the throw Brown down back). I would be picking at least one guy who you are very confident will finish top 6 for Fwds, and shape from there.

Overall, the structure isn't too bad, but I feel that you have way too many PODs overall- a team like this either pays off in spades, or gets dismally buried, and the latter is far more likely.

[fasttrack13]

Adcock needs to be traded out...
I like your mids... I think you have 3 10-20 players instead of majority top 10 mids...
Love your Blicavs pick but I don't like lobbe personally!
Zorko and walker I don't think will be top 10 but I love sheed as a pod! Could go 95-105 average!