Player X vs Player Y

[Adamant]

Gibbs v Wines

I like Gibbs to bounce back this year under Bolton and currently have him at M5. Wondering if I should find a bit more money to upgrade to Wines though?

I think Wines has more potential to be elite but the lack of outside ball he gets might restrict his scoring a bit imo.

Gibbs should be a safe bet to average 100 again but whether that's good enough to be in your midfield by seasons end I'm not sure. I currently have him in at M7 but he's not locked in by any means.

Another guy I like around that price range is Dylan Shiel.

[Rusty00]

Gibbs v Wines

I like Gibbs to bounce back this year under Bolton and currently have him at M5. Wondering if I should find a bit more money to upgrade to Wines though?

I think Wines has more potential to be elite but the lack of outside ball he gets might restrict his scoring a bit imo.

Gibbs should be a safe bet to average 100 again but whether that's good enough to be in your midfield by seasons end I'm not sure. I currently have him in at M7 but he's not locked in by any means.

Another guy I like around that price range is Dylan Shiel.

Yeah this is exactly what my thought process is at the moment.

[Barra13]

Matt Rosa or Brodie Smith or Nick Malceski? Need a D4 under 431k. Any others I should look at?

[Mr.Craig]

Mmmm, I'd say Smith.

Only other one I'd really look at around that bracket would be Z.Williams but a bit too risky for DT.

[Football Factory]

Tom Sheridan  :-X

I think he can go 75-80 easily (priced at 65) which will net him a nice little price rise and could easily hold down D5,D6 not always easy to upgrade all players in DT. At the moment I have have him at D4 in all formats  :o call me mad if you wish but I can see something in this guy and im not normally one to talk up players in this price bracket.

[Mr.Craig]

That's if he can hold on to his marks this year. :P

[Ricochet]

That's if he can hold on to his marks this year. :P

:'(

[Heatrod]

Danger vs T.Adams?

Both look to be absolute jets this year, finding it very hard choose between the two.

My other premos are Fyfe, Rocky and Ablett

[Mat0369]

Conca vs Simpkin

I've got Simpkin in SC and I am not considering Conca due to how much he is priced, but in DT he is 20k cheaper then Simpkin

[Rusty00]

Conca vs Simpkin

I've got Simpkin in SC and I am not considering Conca due to how much he is priced, but in DT he is 20k cheaper then Simpkin

I know it's only NAB but I'm starting to turn off Simpkin in general. Not sure I really like either as an option but if I had to choose I'd have to say Conca.

Sidey v Adams?

Trying to figure out whether there was a reason for Adams better scoring after the byes last year or whether it was just him improving as a player in general after a slow start to the year.

[Mat0369]

I know it's only NAB but I'm starting to turn off Simpkin in general. Not sure I really like either as an option but if I had to choose I'd have to say Conca.

Sidey v Adams?

Trying to figure out whether there was a reason for Adams better scoring after the byes last year or whether it was just him improving as a player in general after a slow start to the year.

I am pretty much giving him one more NAB in regards to my SC team but I think he is too expensive for DT at his price anyway. He is 275k compared to Conca at 255k who is priced at 45 but averaged 77 the year before. He is a bit of a butcher with the ball but it doesn't really matter in DT.

Adams is going to get a lot of the ball, similar to Conca in that he is a butcher, but he will win a ton of the pill. Sidebottom I prefer in SC because of his ball use and the fact he hits the scoreboard. There are a couple of other options at the price I prefer, but if I had to pick one it would maybe be Sidebottom just due to his consistency.

[Barra13]

Sidebottom will be playing a bit more forward this year along with Swan and Pendles off the back allowing the likes of Adams, Treloar into the middle.

[Rusty00]

Dusty + S Gray vs Robbo + Greene

[Barra13]

What are your other forwards?

[Rusty00]

????, Barlow, ?????, Wells, Kerridge, Milera, McCarthy, McDonald-Tip