Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, December 22, 2015, 02:28:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sabretooth Tigers

 ::)

Hi guys and gals. Planning on finally finishing my back line and could use some help with the 6th position.
I have 7 possibles with Shaw and Docherty already in. Here they are:-
Shaw,  Docherty,  Rance,  Simpson,  Howe,  McVeigh,  Bartel.
Ideally I'm after set and forget here as I still have problems in the guts and forward line i.e  Liberatore, Cripps (Car), Hall and still have 1 (Monty) upgrade in the forward line. Envisage a full team of prems with only 5 trades left.  Help !!     ;)

GoLions

Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on June 20, 2016, 04:58:22 PM
::)

Hi guys and gals. Planning on finally finishing my back line and could use some help with the 6th position.
I have 7 possibles with Shaw and Docherty already in. Here they are:-
Shaw,  Docherty,  Rance,  Simpson,  Howe,  McVeigh,  Bartel.
Ideally I'm after set and forget here as I still have problems in the guts and forward line i.e  Liberatore, Cripps (Car), Hall and still have 1 (Monty) upgrade in the forward line. Envisage a full team of prems with only 5 trades left.  Help !!     ;)
Simmo or Rance, I'd go Simmo

Huttabito

Who to bring in this week, other next week.

Docherty (BE 135 vs GWS)
vs
Montagna (BE 130 vs Geel)

Mark

Ok so besides GoLions.. Does anyone think it worth paying the extra $$ for Zorko or save $$ and buy Montagna ??

Sabretooth Tigers

Quote from: GoLions on June 20, 2016, 04:59:34 PM
Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on June 20, 2016, 04:58:22 PM
::)

Hi guys and gals. Planning on finally finishing my back line and could use some help with the 6th position.
I have 7 possibles with Shaw and Docherty already in. Here they are:-
Shaw,  Docherty,  Rance,  Simpson,  Howe,  McVeigh,  Bartel.
Ideally I'm after set and forget here as I still have problems in the guts and forward line i.e  Liberatore, Cripps (Car), Hall and still have 1 (Monty) upgrade in the forward line. Envisage a full team of prems with only 5 trades left.  Help !!     ;)
Simmo or Rance, I'd go Simmo

Thanks GL. I was down to Simmo,  Bartel  and  Rance  in  my  calculations.  Will bring Bartel and Simmo in this week, then McVeigh next and Howe the week or so after. Cheers mate.    ;)

dylanclements

Quote from: Huttabito on June 20, 2016, 05:34:13 PM
Docherty (BE 135 vs GWS)
vs
Montagna (BE 130 vs Geel)

Neither are going anywhere in price quickly, whichever suits byes I reckon


Quote from: Mark on June 20, 2016, 05:49:43 PM
Ok so besides GoLions.. Does anyone think it worth paying the extra $$ for Zorko or save $$ and buy Montagna ??

I said Joey before but if it's your last spot I'm changing my mind, I reckon ZZZZZorko is a must haves this season

Sabretooth Tigers

Quote from: Mark on June 20, 2016, 05:49:43 PM
Ok so besides GoLions.. Does anyone think it worth paying the extra $$ for Zorko or save $$ and buy Montagna ??

Reckon Zorko will out score Monty enough to warrant the extra $$$ plus show a profit.      ;)

Ringo

Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on June 20, 2016, 06:42:00 PM
Quote from: Mark on June 20, 2016, 05:49:43 PM
Ok so besides GoLions.. Does anyone think it worth paying the extra $$ for Zorko or save $$ and buy Montagna ??

Reckon Zorko will out score Monty enough to warrant the extra $$$ plus show a profit.      ;)
If byes not an issue pay up for Zorko but if Rd 15 byes is an issue (like me) than go with Tags.  I will probably have both and hope Zorks keeps up his 90 - 100 score this week to drop further.  ;)

Blues Blues Blues

Need to upgrade DBJ to a premo defender.

Thinking:

Rance ($477k) - proven gun, averaging 98
Or
Laird ($472k) - averaging 96 and cheap
Or
McVeigh ($443k) - only averaging 87 but can he get back to lofty heights of yesteryear?

Currently have Shaw, Docherty, Simmo, Adams, Tippa, DBJ, Collins, Lee.

Adams and Tip will be last upgrades, Collins can be bench cover. Lee can sit there and be the retard that he is.

Mark

Quote from: Ringo on June 20, 2016, 07:10:26 PM
Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on June 20, 2016, 06:42:00 PM
Quote from: Mark on June 20, 2016, 05:49:43 PM
Ok so besides GoLions.. Does anyone think it worth paying the extra $$ for Zorko or save $$ and buy Montagna ??

Reckon Zorko will out score Monty enough to warrant the extra $$$ plus show a profit.      ;)
If byes not an issue pay up for Zorko but if Rd 15 byes is an issue (like me) than go with Tags.  I will probably have both and hope Zorks keeps up his 90 - 100 score this week to drop further.  ;)

Yeah might get Montagna this week and hope Zorko has a stinker and drops $$ then have 2 weeks to get him in after his bye. Fingers crossed.

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 20, 2016, 09:27:04 PM
Need to upgrade DBJ to a premo defender.

Thinking:

Rance ($477k) - proven gun, averaging 98
Or
Laird ($472k) - averaging 96 and cheap
Or
McVeigh ($443k) - only averaging 87 but can he get back to lofty heights of yesteryear?

Currently have Shaw, Docherty, Simmo, Adams, Tippa, DBJ, Collins, Lee.

Adams and Tip will be last upgrades, Collins can be bench cover. Lee can sit there and be the retard that he is.

Rance being only 5k more sounds good and usually scores above 85

Best of luck

WizzFizz

Rich adams d6 and 7 vs Boyd/johanissen/laird and tucker d6 and 7

also boyd/johanissen/laird to snap up in the coming weeks

Swoozie

Dusty or Delidio for a POD?

Delidio is a about 40k cheaper which could help a lot considering I don't have a lot of trades or cash to play with (Cheers Dahlhaus, Tippett and Nic Nat)

HotTiges

rance and pendles

vs

docherty and sloane/treloar/steven/mid tier premo

King_Robbo

Quote from: Swoozie on June 20, 2016, 11:20:18 PM
Dusty or Delidio for a POD?

Delidio is a about 40k cheaper which could help a lot considering I don't have a lot of trades or cash to play with (Cheers Dahlhaus, Tippett and Nic Nat)
Martin is a Mus have this year. He is now playing mainly through the midfield and looks basically untaggable. I wouldn't be surprised if he continues to knock out some big tonnes. Will easily average more than lids and montagna

Raiden

Can only grab 1 this week, then the other the following week.

Rance (BE 93) Vs Bris @ the MCG

Or

Laird (BE 105) Vs Nth @ AO

Thinking Rance is more likely to exceed his BE this week & rise the most?