Player X v Player Y

[enzedder]

Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

I think Brand and Zorko - who knows when def rooks will come up.

Priddis v Sloane?

Priddis but merit in Sloane. Like both.

Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

Hard to know without seeing your full team Enz.  All things being equal, after considering bye balance, cash flow and future trades, Zorko has been ultra consistent and Dochers will be cheaper later on.  Paying full price for any defender except Heater is money lost I reckon.  They always come down.  Macpherson looks pretty safe for now, given GCS issues.  Matheison on the horizon though.  Do you have a spot for him?

Yeah mate. Still got Oliver, Bennedy, Menadue or even Wells to swing into mids for downgrade/ upgrade in coming rounds. Only 3 premium defenders atm... Rance, Shaw & Laird so with Laird out Docherty gives support down back this week but if I go Docherty I've got to field Menadue.
Thinking I'll do defenders last... Docherty is at a relatively high price, though BE is low... If he will be cheaper it will be much later...prefer Zorko as an upgrade all the same. Still weighing it up.

[pikla]

Simpson or Docherty? Can't split them.

I like Simpson but worried he will be rested more often.

Thoughts?

[ants]

Simpson or Docherty? Can't split them.

I like Simpson but worried he will be rested more often.

Thoughts?

i like them both! and will have both in finals team!

[Judd Magic]

Barlow > Montagna or Wells > Montagna

Menadue on the ground if I go Barlow > Montagna

Menadue not on the ground if Barlow is a late in and I go Wells > Montagna.

[tommy10]

Which option:
1.Wells to Bartel + 220k. With Laird will give me 4 premos (Shaw, Simmo the other premos)
2. Wells to Montagna + 185k
3. Wells to Dahl + 148k (prob won't have enough to upgrade to mid premo next week)
Already have Zorko, Dusty, Barlow and Hall.

[tommy10]

Simpson or Docherty? Can't split them.

I like Simpson but worried he will be rested more often.

Thoughts?

i like them both! and will have both in finals team!

Simmo !!! Docherty after the bye.

[Big Mac]

Simpson or Docherty? Can't split them.

I like Simpson but worried he will be rested more often.

Thoughts?

Simpson is a machine I doubt he will be rested

I'm going Docherty though to save a little $$

[js19]

Simpson or Docherty? Can't split them.

I like Simpson but worried he will be rested more often.

Thoughts?

Simpson is a machine I doubt he will be rested

I'm going Docherty though to save a little $$

8 of the last 10 seasons, Simmo has played every game, and has missed a total of 5 of 220 games! Usually selected because he is extremely durable and consistent, and even though he's older, will more than likely play every game barring injury/suspension

[Vinny]

Joey or Dahl?

[tommy10]

Joey or Dahl?

I'd go Dahl mate but Joey for this week may take the chocolates.
Btw let's hope Real win the CL next week  :)

[Blues Blues Blues]

Who out of these 3 this week:

Priddis $502k (BE 66)
Gray $514k (BE 135)
Parker $554 (BE 137)

More concerned about who will score most for rest of the year.

[Jimmykidd]

Who out of these 3 this week:

Priddis $502k (BE 66)
Gray $514k (BE 135)
Parker $554 (BE 137)

More concerned about who will score most for rest of the year.

Gray at that price.

[PICCOLLO]

Who out of these 3 this week:

Priddis $502k (BE 66)
Gray $514k (BE 135)
Parker $554 (BE 137)

More concerned about who will score most for rest of the year.

Priddis.

[mzunguman]

Neale v Coniglio

[jfitty]

Neale v Coniglio

Trying to decide between these two and Ward.. So I'll piggy back on here.

I just can't split the 3 of them