Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, December 22, 2015, 02:28:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jfitty

Enright vs Bartel?

Also looking at Pittard and McVeigh..

Love Enright as a POD, but Bartel seems to have found some form

enzedder

Quote from: jfitty on May 17, 2016, 10:18:30 AM
Enright vs Bartel?

Also looking at Pittard and McVeigh..

Love Enright as a POD, but Bartel seems to have found some form
Bartel over Enright in that Bartel has been a better SC pick and being a utility he has many ways to score. If on the ball or given free license he rakes in the points. Nothing wrong with Enright coming in this week as he has bottomed out with his low score. Proven defender and averaging well but think Bartel will average more from here in.
McVeigh over Pittard as Pittard sucks. Had him last year after he was in all Australian form early, didn't last and he didn't stay in my team. Think his bubble will burst again and when he scores low it is real low.
McVeigh on the other hand is proven and cheap... I'm still watching him and think I'll get him... He is cheap atm having lost 70k. He has a BE of 125ish this week too.
If you have to get one this week I'd recommend Jimmy but McVeigh could be the way to go next week... Juicy.... I almost wouldn't mind if he tonned up this weekend... Will still lose cash and show he can still produce. As it is he's got consistent 80s which is okay for a defender.

mzunguman


supercoachhelp


Fid


GoLions


MC

Quote from: mzunguman on May 17, 2016, 03:00:25 PM
Brand v Macpherson

Depends on your team mate. Macpherson should outscore Brand, though there are more mid rookies on the horizon than def rookies. Macpherson being a round 13 bye player means he probably won't be ready to trade before his bye either.

mzunguman

Quote from: MC on May 18, 2016, 07:55:42 PM
Quote from: mzunguman on May 17, 2016, 03:00:25 PM
Brand v Macpherson

Depends on your team mate. Macpherson should outscore Brand, though there are more mid rookies on the horizon than def rookies. Macpherson being a round 13 bye player means he probably won't be ready to trade before his bye either.

Seeing as Matheison is going to debut I think I'll be going brand instead
Thanks everyone

Jimmykidd


GoLions


Puppetry


enzedder

Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

Thewizz71

Quote from: enzedder on May 20, 2016, 03:33:33 PM
Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

I think Brand and Zorko - who knows when def rooks will come up.

Priddis v Sloane?

PICCOLLO

Quote from: enzedder on May 20, 2016, 03:33:33 PM
Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

Hard to know without seeing your full team Enz.  All things being equal, after considering bye balance, cash flow and future trades, Zorko has been ultra consistent and Dochers will be cheaper later on.  Paying full price for any defender except Heater is money lost I reckon.  They always come down.  Macpherson looks pretty safe for now, given GCS issues.  Matheison on the horizon though.  Do you have a spot for him?

mzunguman

#2384
Quote from: Thewizz71 on May 20, 2016, 03:36:58 PM
Quote from: enzedder on May 20, 2016, 03:33:33 PM
Adams and Crouch gone...but to who?
Brand Zorko or Docherty Macherson

I think Brand and Zorko - who knows when def rooks will come up.

Priddis v Sloane?

I like Sloane, tackling machine who seems to have hit his straps!... still not sold on Priddis' form as well

Neale + 60K v Hanners v Joey + 95k... ????