Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, December 22, 2015, 02:28:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mark


Torpedo10

Jelwood looks a must now, but I went Priddis.

Had a gut feeling from the start of the week that Matty was going to do well.

jfitty

#2252
Pittard vs Houli?

Looking to get one of these guys next week for Tippa.

I'm leaning towards Bachar since the scars of having Pittard last year are still healing :(

For argument's sake, let's say they both score 90+

EDIT: Could get McVeigh too, assuming he drops a bit more. But 2 of these 3 will come in to complete my backline I'd say, just have to pick the right ones

fanTCfool

Simmo vs M Boyd?
Kade misses less games, but Boyd has the potential to score a little higher, though is nearly finished his Etihad Stadium run.

Jimmykidd

Quote from: fanTCfool on May 02, 2016, 06:20:48 PM
Simmo vs M Boyd?
Kade misses less games, but Boyd has the potential to score a little higher, though is nearly finished his Etihad Stadium run.

+1

boyd hitting form but will definitely miss games. simmo mr consistant. think ill be getting simo for weits

_wato

Boyd v Houli v Simpson

Thinking Boyd although the fear of missing games is there. Just think that with the dogs losing Murph all year and JJ for at least half of it, they can't really rest him because their draw gets tough from here and to drop anymore games (they're 4-2) might hinder any possibility of a top 4 spot. Saying that, because I believe him to be the best scorer out of the 3 and is coming off back to back 120's.

Can't go Shaw until later on now which is a bummer but gonna have to live with it.

mzunguman

I like Simpson more than Boyd, he is just the kind of consistency and you know exactly what your gonna get. He's a safe bet. Boyd would be next for me... dont like the draw coming up for the dogs, and we still dont know how they are going to go outside of etihad!
houli is last for me... i have him but he is an absolute rollercoaster... gotta love the 140 but will come out next week and crack a 50!

Selwood V Dahlhaus

_wato

I dunno, Simpson won't continue to average 100, whereas Boyd could easily go 105. 

Jelwood easy, depends on team structure though

Asparagus

#2258
Quote from: mzunguman on May 03, 2016, 10:39:38 AM
I like Simpson more than Boyd, he is just the kind of consistency and you know exactly what your gonna get. He's a safe bet. Boyd would be next for me... dont like the draw coming up for the dogs, and we still dont know how they are going to go outside of etihad!
houli is last for me... i have him but he is an absolute rollercoaster... gotta love the 140 but will come out next week and crack a 50!

Selwood V Dahlhaus
Easy.
He is back to his best with Danger by his side.
Plus the dogs have a few tough games on the road coming up in the next month.

Dogs play Crows/Dees/GWS/Pies/WC

Cats play WC/Crows/Pies/Blus/GWS

HAHA it's almost the same.

mzunguman

Quote from: _wato on May 03, 2016, 10:42:46 AM
I dunno, Simpson won't continue to average 100, whereas Boyd could easily go 105. 

Jelwood easy, depends on team structure though

Taking Jelwood would give me 6 premiums + Libba

Simpson might not average 100, but I feel definetly 95ish! Boyd hasn't played a full season for 3/4 years! He'll miss a few matches so does Boyd missing matches still outweigh someone like simpson? I personally would take the security of simpson :)

Bubbles

Parker v Ward v Selwood

Judd Magic


crowls

if starting from scratch,  prob selwood, ward, parker.
ward/parker likely to be my last decision in mids.    soft spot for Ward so probably go his way.   

ants

menadue or davis for the chop?

Bully

Quote from: ants on May 04, 2016, 11:53:00 AM
menadue or davis for the chop?

Both have a similar BE however I think Davis will get the chop this week, has been very uninspiring.