Player X v Player Y

[Big Mac]

Should I hold or keep westhoff?

Just had a look at his scores this year and wow!

PB please explain

[Mark]

Dea to Priddis, Selwood, Ward or Hanners

[Judd Magic]

Dea to Priddis, Selwood, Ward or Hanners

Hanners.

[Judd Magic]

Hannebery vs Pendles vs Selwood?

Already have Danger and now Parker if that makes any difference.

[whynot102]

Brought in Hanners and Selwood howver hard to go past Pendles thinking of changing as have Danger and no Pjss yetquote author=Judd Magic link=topic=105273.msg1752969#msg1752969 date=1461844671]
Hannebery vs Pendles vs Selwood?

Already have Danger and now Parker if that makes any difference.
[/quote]

[backpocket]

Should I hold or keep westhoff?

Just had a look at his scores this year and wow!

PB please explain

Definately not why I picked him however the loss of Schulz has killed him IMO, the first game that they both played and hoff had his usual roaming role he scored 100+ after that when shulz got injured he's been playing full forward, no ball is getting down there same as wingard and hinkley Imo as one of the most one dimensional coaches ever isn't taking advantage of these multi positional players. Therefore Hoffs appalling scores... Which peeses me off more because with his scores I'm still top 5000 lol

[Marstar]

Should I hold or keep westhoff?

Just had a look at his scores this year and wow!

PB please explain

Definately not why I picked him however the loss of Schulz has killed him IMO, the first game that they both played and hoff had his usual roaming role he scored 100+ after that when shulz got injured he's been playing full forward, no ball is getting down there same as wingard and hinkley Imo as one of the most one dimensional coaches ever isn't taking advantage of these multi positional players. Therefore Hoffs appalling scores... Which peeses me off more because with his scores I'm still top 5000 lol

I've watch all their games and I was a big advocate of the Westoff bandwagon preseason ....

It's been like Where's Wally?  Monty needs to give him a permanent magnifying glass symbol.

He's being swung back and forward constantly and for many quarters he's been at the wrong end of the momentum, literally have not seen him on the screen near the ball for 10+ minute stretches.

Port continue to bomb long to Dixon every opportunity they get. In the GWS game (i believe), when Westoff played FF he sat in the goal square every time it came in ... with clear instructions to literally watched Dixon contest ... with his only goal for the day coming from 1 spillage over the top for a cheap score. 2 of his goals in other games have actually come from leading up to 15m kick in from a deliberate out of bounds ... it's an absolute joke.

[Ingram]

Parker + Hold Bennedy VS Hanners + Bennedy to Pretracca.

Liking Hanners over Parker but need the extra cash to afford him unfortunately.

[hawkboy80]

Montagna/Hall/Dahlhaus/Z Merrett?

Hall for mine. Super consistent.

I'll ask again.

Hanners vs Parker  :P

am really interested if ppl have a comment here, apart from ownership % and price why would you take either 1 over the other?

[vtaced]

Selwood, Hanners, Ward or Priddis?

[Raiden]

Selwood, Hanners, Ward or Priddis?

Hanners > Selwood > Priddis > Ward

[Jimmykidd]

Montagna/Hall/Dahlhaus/Z Merrett?

Hall for mine. Super consistent.

I'll ask again.

Hanners vs Parker  :P

am really interested if ppl have a comment here, apart from ownership % and price why would you take either 1 over the other?

hanners will back up last year i think. people have been burnt by parker so theres doubts. but i think this year ultimately you need both. hanners might drop so parker for now is my choice.

[wetDT]

had to hold JJ so trading now.

Whose more critical to bring in this week

Heater or Simmo?

[Ringo]

Simpson has the lower B/e which he will achieve so on that basis Simpson.

[Big Mac]

Montagna/Hall/Dahlhaus/Z Merrett?

Hall for mine. Super consistent.

I'll ask again.

Hanners vs Parker  :P

am really interested if ppl have a comment here, apart from ownership % and price why would you take either 1 over the other?

Imo Hanners is pretty much guaranteed top 6 mids, Parker I'm not 100% on yet (will probably make it into my side at some stage though)