Player X v Player Y

[Jay]

JPK vs Sidebottom vs Sloane vs Treloar

I personally like Treloar out of those options but I don't think you can go wrong with any really.

R.Gray v Smitchell
and
Kennedy v Oliver v Parish

thanks guys.

Cheers mate. I'm really struggling to separate them.

As for your situation, I'd go Gray and Parish

[MC]

Cheers for all of the responses guys, seems like Greene is a resounding victor then.

JPK vs Sidebottom vs Sloane vs Treloar

JPK > Treloar > Sloane > Sidey

R.Gray v Smitchell
and
Kennedy v Oliver v Parish

thanks guys.

Gray and Parish imo

[Money Shot]

Looks like Gray and Parish it is.

Was thinking Parish purely because of his breakeven.
I think Gray is my choice out of the second two as well.

[enzedder]

This is a good point - if you can avoid posting your X v Y till after the previous one has had at least one reply it would be appreciated.

Scrolling through the thread as i can I have found some 4 requests still not answered due to another being requested and then getting lost.

Do not want to go down the path of deleting requests but if you can not observe the simple courtesy of waiting for at least one reply on the previous I may take that action.  There is also no reason why you can not comment and then post your own.

As mods we are also merging some new topics into this thread so hence the need for courtesy/

In many respects I hate this X vs Y thread. We didn't use to have it.
The reasons I don't like it are: you can post and it gets lost for the reasons stated above (this has happened to me), if you get a reply it is often just the one... and one and you're left wanting more.
As for merging threads that can be annoying too, particularly if you are running a poll.
Polls were once one of my favourite features of fan footy but for some reason they all disappear and get lost in a merged thread where you don't get all feedback that is specific to your wants.
My 2 cents. Perhaps it's not the forum....feel free to delete it or put in in another thread. :P

[BomberSam]

Probably need to trade Big Stef.

Nic Nat vs. Gawn?

[Bubbles]

Laird v Rance

Already have Shaw and Houli

[BomberSam]

Laird v Rance

Already have Shaw and Houli

Go Laird. Number one defender this year.

[Elcapitano]

Laird v Rance

Already have Shaw and Houli

Go Laird. Number one defender this year.

Laird for me too, Consistently will hit 100's.. Rance will throw in the odd stinker


im tossing up between Ward vs Zorko

[BomberSam]

Laird v Rance

Already have Shaw and Houli

Go Laird. Number one defender this year.

Laird for me too, Consistently will hit 100's.. Rance will throw in the odd stinker


im tossing up between Ward vs Zorko

Ward is looking majestic.

[mzunguman]

Ward in the Mids or Dalhaus in the FWDs?

[crowls]

Probably need to trade Big Stef.

Nic Nat vs. Gawn?

I went to Goldy as had Gawn.   If you have Goldy would go Gawn.   Motivated, young strong and getting better.   

[Jimmykidd]

zerrett vs zaka.

replacing sam gray.

[ants]

if stef plays i want to get rid of 2 of these 3 donkeys! sheridan,lonergan and seedsman! leaning towards sheridan and lonergan as they are worth more and a higher BE thoughts?

[whynot102]

Merrett in the fwds or Parker in the mids

[Asparagus]

Merrett in the fwds or Parker in the mids

this