Player X v Player Y

[jfitty]

One last spot to fill, and it has me stumped. Can be defense, or fwd if I swing tippa to backs and lose my fwd/def link. $145,000 to spend.

So it's McGovern vs Papley vs Hartley (not playing). I think Hartley has to be close to selection, but I already have a R3 donut, so not sure if it's worth the risk?

I'd go Papley out of those 3. Don't want to carry Hartley if he doesn't get named, and I think Papley has slightly better JS than McGovern

[steven3]

What order for:
Jacobs vs S.Martin vs NicNat

[BLBBLB]

Cutler vs. Seedsman?

L parker + m robinson vs. Pendles + T Greene?

[crowls]

Cutler vs. Seedsman?

L parker + m robinson vs. Pendles + T Greene?

pendles greene    and seedsman

[almonds]

Lonergan v seedsman

[steven3]

Lonergan v seedsman

Lonergan

Order for nicnat jacobs and s.martin?

[Fid]

Lonergan v seedsman

Lonergan

Order for nicnat jacobs and s.martin?

Nicnat Martin Jacobs

[BLBBLB]

Shiel + Parker + L McCarthy vs. Pendles + T Greene + Hewett and 60k to spend elsewhere.

[steven3]

Shiel + Parker + L McCarthy vs. Pendles + T Greene + Hewett and 60k to spend elsewhere.

Pendles S.Gray Hewett + 20k

Second guessing all my choices thanks to hartley
Danger vs ablett
Ward vs shiel
Laird vs roberton

[Samsturmfels]

Shiel + Parker + L McCarthy vs. Pendles + T Greene + Hewett and 60k to spend elsewhere.

id probably do the second option although both seem quite good. now i have one...

De goey + Crouch vs Mid premo + rookie

[dicko_]

De goey + Crouch vs Mid premo + rookie

I really like Crouch, but would have to go with the second option, if the premium is really high end, like 600k, and the rookie has reasonable js as well. I'm not convinced that de Goey will deliver simply based off nab form, and always avoid second year players regardless.

Starting to worry a bit about the js of some of these rookies, and the freedom that shaw will get. So wondering about:

eMac + Yeo v Shaw + Papley?

[steven3]

De goey + Crouch vs Mid premo + rookie

I really like Crouch, but would have to go with the second option, if the premium is really high end, like 600k, and the rookie has reasonable js as well. I'm not convinced that de Goey will deliver simply based off nab form, and always avoid second year players regardless.

Starting to worry a bit about the js of some of these rookies, and the freedom that shaw will get. So wondering about:

eMac + Yeo v Shaw + Papley?

Shaw and papley. Getting a top 3 defender

Danger vs ablett
Ward vs shiel vs selwood
Laird vs roberton

[Jackross10]

De goey + Crouch vs Mid premo + rookie

I really like Crouch, but would have to go with the second option, if the premium is really high end, like 600k, and the rookie has reasonable js as well. I'm not convinced that de Goey will deliver simply based off nab form, and always avoid second year players regardless.

Starting to worry a bit about the js of some of these rookies, and the freedom that shaw will get. So wondering about:

eMac + Yeo v Shaw + Papley?

Shaw and papley. Getting a top 3 defender

Danger vs ablett
Ward vs shiel vs selwood
Laird vs roberton

[NickyBoy]

which 3 rookies to pick for m9-m11

Petrecca, Dunkley, Davis, Gresham, Hewett,

I was leaning towards Davis, Gresham and Dunkley. Thoughts?

[Samsturmfels]

which 3 rookies to pick for m9-m11

Petrecca, Dunkley, Davis, Gresham, Hewett,

I was leaning towards Davis, Gresham and Dunkley. Thoughts?

Id pick Hewett over Dunkley, however i dont exactly know enough about Dunkley