Player X v Player Y

[LaHug]

Mitch McGovern vs. Tom Papley?

Tough call, think McGocern is more likely to keep his spot, papley better scoring potential. I think risk it on Papley

I wish I could afford someone less dodgy... already have McCarthy, Milera, Bennedy, Kerridge so it's just that awful F8 spot.

[SC_Dave]

I need as many opinions as possible... Wines vs. Shiel.

shiel

Ollie Wines for mine.

Midfield bench :  Brant Colledge (WC) v George Hewett (Syd)

[dmac07]

Mitch McGovern vs. Tom Papley?

Tough call, think McGocern is more likely to keep his spot, papley better scoring potential. I think risk it on Papley

I wish I could afford someone less dodgy... already have McCarthy, Milera, Bennedy, Kerridge so it's just that awful F8 spot.

Same, but it also seems a waste to have Milera and McCarthy both on my bemch. I also went Papley so I could Petracca to Gresham

[LaHug]

Mitch McGovern vs. Tom Papley?

Tough call, think McGocern is more likely to keep his spot, papley better scoring potential. I think risk it on Papley

I wish I could afford someone less dodgy... already have McCarthy, Milera, Bennedy, Kerridge so it's just that awful F8 spot.

Same, but it also seems a waste to have Milera and McCarthy both on my bemch. I also went Papley so I could Petracca to Gresham

You'd take Gresham over Hewett, yeah?

[tommy10]

Lonergan, Shiel, Hewett and DeGoey
v
JJ, Brouch, Oliver and Buddy
v
Gibson, Brouch, Hewett, Hall + 64k

[enzedder]

Mitch McGovern vs. Tom Papley?

Tough call, think McGocern is more likely to keep his spot, papley better scoring potential. I think risk it on Papley

I wish I could afford someone less dodgy... already have McCarthy, Milera, Bennedy, Kerridge so it's just that awful F8 spot.

Same, but it also seems a waste to have Milera and McCarthy both on my bemch. I also went Papley so I could Petracca to Gresham

You'd take Gresham over Hewett, yeah?

Yeah mate. That looks  a given. Saints have big wraps on him. Hewett's JS looks a lot shakier.

[blackrose]

Sidebottom vs Shiel?

[Elcapitano]

Shiel... looks set to become elite!

With Hartley not named I'm now restructuring my D1-3

Boyd, Bartel, Smith

Vs

Laird, Bartel, Rich/Smith??

[barlowlove]

Rich, De Goey, Hewett M10 v Gibson, Milera, Oliver M9

Option 2, just. Mainly because I don't really rate the Rich pick myself. From a structure POV, Option 1 probably makes more sense than having Oliver on the bench (an issue I'm also dealing with)

Midfield bench :  Brant Colledge (WC) v George Hewett (Syd)

Hewett, could be good sneaky cash cow if he holds his place for a few weeks!

Sidebottom vs Shiel?

Shiel

Lonergan, Shiel, Hewett and DeGoey
v
JJ, Brouch, Oliver and Buddy
v
Gibson, Brouch, Hewett, Hall + 64k

Hmm, probably the 1st option!

Last big dilemma for me:

Option 1: Libba, Crouch, Hartley and 87k (possibly for Hewett to Oliver at M10)
Option 2: Oliver, Crouch and Lonergan
Option 3A: Libba, Oliver and Longeran (downgrade Laird to Birchall)
Option 3B: Libba, Oliver and Lonergan (downgrade Danger to Robbie Gray)

Sorry if its confusing and cheers to anyone who responds!

[dmac07]

Mitch McGovern vs. Tom Papley?

Tough call, think McGocern is more likely to keep his spot, papley better scoring potential. I think risk it on Papley

I wish I could afford someone less dodgy... already have McCarthy, Milera, Bennedy, Kerridge so it's just that awful F8 spot.

Same, but it also seems a waste to have Milera and McCarthy both on my bemch. I also went Papley so I could Petracca to Gresham

You'd take Gresham over Hewett, yeah?

Yeah mate. That looks  a given. Saints have big wraps on him. Hewett's JS looks a lot shakier.

I like both, Ive gone Gresham, Hewett and Davis on mid bench.

[frenzy]

Pendles and Simpkin   Vs   Jelwood and B Crouch

[almonds]

hanners vs shiel

[barlowlove]

Pendles and Simpkin   Vs   Jelwood and B Crouch

Selwood and Crouch for sure

[GVSKiwi]

Pendles and Simpkin   Vs   Jelwood and B Crouch

Jelwood and B Crouch.


Greene v Hall (season average)

[Jay]

Pendles and Simpkin   Vs   Jelwood and B Crouch

Jelwood and B Crouch.


Greene v Hall (season average)

I'd say Hall has the higher upside, but Greene will average more.