Player X v Player Y

[almonds]

J.Lonergan v P.Seedsman

[Holz]

J.Lonergan v P.Seedsman

lonergan will probably outscore him in the first 8 weeks so if you want a stepping stone lonergan. if you want a keeper then seedsman i think will beat him over a season.

[almonds]

J.Lonergan v P.Seedsman

lonergan will probably outscore him in the first 8 weeks so if you want a stepping stone lonergan. if you want a keeper then seedsman i think will beat him over a season.

ill reword
lonergan v seedsman (average)

[MontyJnr]

Lonergan + Shiel v Bartel + Libba

Option one would give me a midfield of Ablett, Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Shiel, Mills, Oliver

I prefer Bartel + Libba

[MontyJnr]

Pendlebury & Oliver vs Joel Selwood & Brad Crouch?

[Jay]

Pendlebury & Oliver vs Joel Selwood & Brad Crouch?

Selwood and Crouch easily to be honest mate.

[Jay]

Dangerfield, Mills, Lobbe

vs

JPK, Hewett, Naitanui

[Raiden]

Dangerfield, Mills, Lobbe

vs

JPK, Hewett, Naitanui

Option 2 - You get two keepers JPK/Nic Nat

[dmac07]

Which 2 of.. Papley, L.McCarthy, Milera, M.McGovern, B.Hardwick.

For two bemch spots so not super keen on picking Milera at 170k on the bench.

[_wato]

Rich, De Goey, Hewett M10 v Gibson, Milera, Oliver M9

[almonds]

Lonergan vs Seedsman ( end of season average)

[_wato]

Which 2 of.. Papley, L.McCarthy, Milera, M.McGovern, B.Hardwick.

For two bemch spots so not super keen on picking Milera at 170k on the bench.

McCarthy deffs one, and probably Milera for JS mate.

Lonergan vs Seedsman ( end of season average)

Seedsman

Dangerfield, Mills, Lobbe

vs

JPK, Hewett, Naitanui

JPK, Nat, Hewett

[almonds]

K.Langford vs M.Mcgovern

[Maca24]

K.Langford vs M.Mcgovern

Langford probably a better option if you have the cash, but I'd throw him on the field as that's a lot of cash on the bench.


Libba vs B.Crouch
Parker vs Shiel vs Treloar

[_wato]

Libba vs B.Crouch
Parker vs Shiel vs Treloar

Both but probs Libba for safety, Crouch a calculated risk. I like both.

Shiel > Parker > Treloar on prices