Player X v Player Y

[GCSkiwi]

Oliver vs parish ?

Tough, I feel Parish has more potential but Oliver has shown more in preseason.

Really it is a same same pick as both, either or none could go gangbusters

I would stick with Oliver as we only saw Parish once in NAB and he's in a team that could get smoked every week, Dees are improving their game so the final points share could be more even to them...

[Judd Magic]

This ^

[Judd Magic]

McCarthy v Milera?

McCarthy.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan v KK and Bartel

And

Oliver v Milera

[no eye deer]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan

v

KK and Bartel

Ha! I was about to ask the same question, except Gibson instead of KK. Got Laird as my other premium. Oliver over Milera for mine.

[dosstheboss]

If Tom Lee is named, Lee v McGovern for that final rookie spot

[Blues Blues Blues]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan

v

KK and Bartel

Ha! I was about to ask the same question, except Gibson instead of KK. Got Laird as my other premium.

What are u leaning towards mate?

[no eye deer]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan

v

KK and Bartel

Ha! I was about to ask the same question, except Gibson instead of KK. Got Laird as my other premium.

What are u leaning towards mate?

Really don't know. I want both Bartell AND Lonergan, but can't find a way to fit them both in and still be strong enough in defense. Maybe option one, but scared to leave out Jimmy.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan

v

KK and Bartel

Ha! I was about to ask the same question, except Gibson instead of KK. Got Laird as my other premium.

What are u leaning towards mate?

Really don't know. I want both Bartell AND Lonergan, but can't find a way to fit them both in and still be strong enough in defense. Maybe option one, but scared to leave out Jimmy.

I've downgraded Cutler and no have Brown at D6, which has allowed me to get Shaw and KK (Houli other premo). I've got my doubts on Jimmy, just feel age catching up. KK I feel is young and ready to burst. Just my opinion of course, I know a lot of others have Jimmy

[no eye deer]

Heath Shaw and Lonergan

v

KK and Bartel

Ha! I was about to ask the same question, except Gibson instead of KK. Got Laird as my other premium.

What are u leaning towards mate?

Really don't know. I want both Bartell AND Lonergan, but can't find a way to fit them both in and still be strong enough in defense. Maybe option one, but scared to leave out Jimmy.

I've downgraded Cutler and no have Brown at D6, which has allowed me to get Shaw and KK (Houli other premo). I've got my doubts on Jimmy, just feel age catching up. KK I feel is young and ready to burst. Just my opinion of course, I know a lot of others have Jimmy

Nice. I can't raise the cash to keep Shaw and have two more premium backs, unless I downgrade Pendles or Gaz. So it comes down to whether I think Lonergan is a good enough D3. He might just have to be for now.

[dosstheboss]

Take 2.    Lee v McGovern?    (presuming lee is named)

[Blues Blues Blues]

Shaw, B Crouch and Bennedy

v

Lonergan, Oliver and Dahlhaus

[jfitty]

Oliver vs parish ?

This is what I'm deciding at the moment.

Feel Oliver might have slightly higher scoring potential, but barring injury you'd expect Parish to play every week.

Just put Parish in, but would love some other thoughts

[Holz]

Bartel Seedsman Oliver

Papely Wilson Hannebary


on field its


Bartel  + Seedsman + Mills

v

Brown/Adams Tippa + Wilson + Hannebary

[Wall-E]

Lonergan + Shiel v Bartel + Libba

Option one would give me a midfield of Ablett, Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Rocky, Shiel, Mills, Oliver