Player X v Player Y

[tommy10]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

[HotTiges]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

option 1...just

mine is..

KK, Shiel, Sam Gray

vs

Rich, Cripps, Dusty

currently using option 1

[MC]

Mackenzie vs Sheridan

Sheridan.

Barlow v Bennell

Barlow easily.

Jpk vs selwood. Both guns.

JPK on the basis of a full pre-season.

Agreed.

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

Option 2 for me, seems more likely for 2 keepers, though I don't rate Oliver that highly to be honest.

mine is..

KK, Shiel, Sam Gray

vs

Rich, Cripps, Dusty

currently using option 1

Yep, option 1.

[aces-high]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

Nn 110 Cripps 110 de goey 85
305

Goldy 125 Oliver 75 Greene 90

290

For balance sake I'd go the top one because I see Cripps as a keeper over Greene and de goey with more growth then Oliver

[AaronKirk]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

Nn 110 Cripps 110 de goey 85
305

Goldy 125 Oliver 75 Greene 90

290

For balance sake I'd go the top one because I see Cripps as a keeper over Greene and de goey with more growth then Oliver

cripps 110? That makes him a top 10 mid. I don't think he will be that high.

For me its NN 105 Cripps 95 and De Goey 80

280

Goldy 120 Oliver 70 Greene 85

275

Option 1... just but Goldy is a captain option.

[aces-high]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

Nn 110 Cripps 110 de goey 85
305

Goldy 125 Oliver 75 Greene 90

290

For balance sake I'd go the top one because I see Cripps as a keeper over Greene and de goey with more growth then Oliver

cripps 110? That makes him a top 10 mid. I don't think he will be that high.

For me its NN 105 Cripps 95 and De Goey 80

280

Goldy 120 Oliver 70 Greene 85

275

Option 1... just but Goldy is a captain option.

Considering Cripps averaged 96 last year in 20 games I think he'll improve to 105+ comfortably which puts him in the top 20 Mids. Nicnat is a top 3 ruck and de goey is a breakout contender that'll make you 150+ cash whilst averaging 80+. Much more upside in that Imo

[MontyJnr]

Weitering & Oliver vs B. Crouch & Broad?

[supercoachhelp]

NN, Cripps and DeGoey vs Goldy, Oliver and Greene

2

[Raiden]

Cripps Vs Wines?

[Raiden]

Weitering & Oliver vs B. Crouch & Broad?

Option 1 -  I don't think Broad will play straight away, however i don't rate Oliver that well either. I'd try to find a way to fit B Crouch in.

[Bubbles]

Bennell/Dahlhaus v Aaron Hall + $138k

[Huttabito]

Bennell/Dahlhaus v Aaron Hall + $138k

Aaron Hall + $138k

Shaw&Lonergan vs Laird&Gibson

[MC]

Cripps Vs Wines?

Wines fairly comfortably. Carlton will still get belted this year, having offloaded most of their experienced blokes.

Bennell/Dahlhaus v Aaron Hall + $138k

Take a punt on Hall if the cash can be effectively used elsewhere. Dahl > Bennell otherwise.

Shaw&Lonergan vs Laird&Gibson

Laird & Gibson will both be keepers, though if you could pick someone else around Gibson's price i'd be happier.

[RaisyDaisy]

Danger & Laird vs Shiel and Heater

[MC]

Danger & Laird vs Shiel and Heater

Danger & Laird for me. Both will be top 5 in their positions, whereas Shiel might suffer without Treloar to back him up - he showed last year he was prone to being tagged completely out of games.