Player X v Player Y

[cortez]

B. Crouch/ Broad or Oliver/ weitering?

[baz1]

Absolutely loving this post!

If you were to drop one, who would it be (and why)?

Fyfe, Danger, Ablett, Rockliff... Or am I crazy and should keep all 4.  ::)

[mzunguman]

B. Crouch/ Broad or Oliver/ weitering?

Oliver Weitering for me

Absolutely loving this post!

If you were to drop one, who would it be (and why)?

Fyfe, Danger, Ablett, Rockliff... Or am I crazy and should keep all 4.  ::)

100% agree!

IF.... I'd drop Ablett just based on the injury niggles... I reckon he's bound to miss games

[Big Mac]

B. Crouch/ Broad or Oliver/ weitering?

Crouch/Broad

[MC]

Rance v Houli v Bartel v Laird

Houli > Laird > Rance > Bartel

Houli over Laird because of his favourable history, Rance as a KPP worries me and Bartel will miss too many games for my liking.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

???

Please help on this one guys and gals. My last one and I can't pick.

B Smith  v J Johannisen

:) ;)

Gut !!!! What's it saying?

B.Smith delivering or flopping?
J.Joh nailing it or failing it?

It's:

Will B.Smith do what we and Adelaide expect him to do
Vs
Can J.Joh do what we and the Doggies expect him to do

My brain says go with the guy you know is capable but failed the mark 1st time round .....

But my gut says that hairdo will tonne up !!!

Thanks "M" the gut says JJ so it's done and dusted. That gives me an unusual defence of :-
T McDonald,  D Rich,  J Johannisen,  T Lonergan,  D Weitering,  M Dea,          //  M Hartley,  M Adams.   Selection night permitting I think I may stick with that.

[Sicko]

Kommer vs Grimley ?

[jvalles69]

Kommer vs Grimley ?

Ugh...

Grimley just for his ruck cover.

[tommy10]

Seedsman vs Harwood

[Sicko]

Seedsman vs Harwood

Seedsman for sure.


Gawn/Dea vs Martin/Hartley??

[MC]

Seedsman vs Harwood

Seedsman for sure.


Gawn/Dea vs Martin/Hartley??

Martin & Hartley imo.
Martin scores less points from HO so will be less effected by the new rulings, Dea apparently has sketchy JS so Hartley over him.

[mzunguman]

S.Martin+Weitering+Oliver v Gawn+Dea+B.Crouch

[nostradamus]

S.Martin+Weitering+Oliver v Gawn+Dea+B.Crouch

Gawn, Dea and B.Crouch ........comfortably

[MC]

S.Martin+Weitering+Oliver v Gawn+Dea+B.Crouch

Gawn, Dea and B.Crouch ........comfortably

Not sure 'comfortably' is the right word...

Martin 110-115 > Gawn 105-110 (+5)
Weitering 80 > Dea 65 (+15)
Oliver 75 < Crouch 95 (-20)

Looks pretty even overall to me, though option #1 will arguably make more cash and help you to have a completed team quicker.

[Ringo]

Degoey (forward) v B Crouch - Would mean playing Wells at F3 Crouch at M7