Player X v Player Y

[TomK]

seedsmen and de goey vs weiters and hall

Weiters and Hall

[nperera95]

wines vs hanners

[TomK]

wines vs hanners

Hanners but depends what you use extra cash if you go Wines though

[BomberSam]

wines vs hanners

Hanners but depends what you use extra cash if you go Wines though

I'd go Wines anyway personally, the cash is a tasty bonus!

[almonds]

Shiel v Parker v Viney

[Vulpes]

I want to drop Houli down to a D6 keeper in the 85-90 range to free up money for rookies, so consider points and cash.

Hurn vs. Rich vs. Lonergan

[Vulpes]

Shiel v Parker v Viney

I reckon Parker > Shiel >> Viney

Parker just on likelihood to play more games.

[MC]

I want to drop Houli down to a D6 keeper in the 85-90 range to free up money for rookies, so consider points and cash.

Hurn vs. Rich vs. Lonergan

Points for price do you mean? Because if it's a keeper you want, cash generation is irrelevant.
As far as keepers go, i'd say:
Hurn > Rich > Lonergan


Hurn (since he broke-out in 2009) has averaged 85SC/19 games over the past 7 seasons, 88 if you exclude last year where he was required to play more accountable footy in the absence of Brown and EMack.
Rich averaged well from day 1, 85 in his first season. Over the same time period, Rich has averaged 83SC/17 games and has been threatening to 'break-out' for years. He could have a spike season, but I think the water has found its level.
Lonergan is the riskiest (also cheapest) but is as yet unproven.

As far as picking a keeper who is more likely to hit that 85-90 mark, I feel Hurn is your man.   

[almonds]

S.Gray v Hall

[piesfan1989]

Hall

[MC]

S.Gray v Hall

Hall for higher fluctuation (better ceiling, lower floor)
Gray for consistency.

Choose according to the level of risk you already have in your team or are willing to take.

[HotTiges]

Rich and Hall

Vs

Lonergan and SGray

D3 AND F3

[jfitty]

S.Gray v Hall

Hall for me.

Finalising my team:

Bartel & Pendlebury or Laird & JPK?

[Sicko]

Rich vs. Yeo?

[HotTiges]

S.Gray v Hall

Hall for me.

Finalising my team:

Bartel & Pendlebury or Laird & JPK?

2nd option..do you have R Gray??