Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

Who do people think would be the best pick out of these guys?

JPK v Sidebottom v Shiel v Treloar v Gaff v Bont v Parker

Looking to bring one of them for last midfield spot have Fyfe, Danger, Hanners, Rocky and Libba already

Im liking Sidebottom at the moment

Where's the Rory option?

That Ablett fella goes alright

[fanTCfool]

Who do people think would be the best pick out of these guys?

JPK v Sidebottom v Shiel v Treloar v Gaff v Bont v Parker

Looking to bring one of them for last midfield spot have Fyfe, Danger, Hanners, Rocky and Libba already

Im liking Sidebottom at the moment

Where's the Rory option?

That Ablett fella goes alright

Can't dispute that, didn't notice his absence

[tommy10]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

[Bully]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

Tough choice indeed, Houli is in very good form and never misses matches, I think he'll be in the top echelon again. The thing that really concerns me with Birch is the graph is headed south, 94, 92, 89, 86, he's also starting to become an injury liability. Parker vs JPK, I'd pick JPK but I think Parker is a value bet just the same. So it's Parker & Houli for me by a whisker.

[Keeper27]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

2nd option. Can you afford jpk/houli??

Sam Gray vs. Stringer as my F4

[Blues Blues Blues]

Rank these blokes

De Goey v D Menzel v Wells v Simpkin

[GoLions]

Wines & Kommer vs Mills & Stringer

Wines and Kommer, although I'd still try and squeeze Mills in if possible

[GoLions]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

2nd option. Can you afford jpk/houli??

Sam Gray vs. Stringer as my F4

I dunno, I wouldn't wanna pick either tbh haha. Maybe Gray? How much do they cost each? May be other options.

[batt]

Rank these blokes

De Goey v D Menzel v Wells v Simpkin

Gee that's tough.

At this stage I'd say:

Wells > De Goey > Simpkin > Menzel

Sidebum & Rance vs Pendles & Suckling

[GoLions]

Rank these blokes

De Goey v D Menzel v Wells v Simpkin

Wells, Simpkin, De Goey, Menzel for me

But I was all over De Goey last year and if he continues this nab form...

[tommy10]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

Tough choice indeed, Houli is in very good form and never misses matches, I think he'll be in the top echelon again. The thing that really concerns me with Birch is the graph is headed south, 94, 92, 89, 86, he's also starting to become an injury liability. Parker vs JPK, I'd pick JPK but I think Parker is a value bet just the same. So it's Parker & Houli for me by a whisker.

Thanks Bully was leaning towards this too.

Will try and get JPK and Houli but something's gotta give...will keep trying

[tommy10]

JPK & Birchall vs Parker & Houli

2nd option. Can you afford jpk/houli??

Sam Gray vs. Stringer as my F4

Stringer just...looks to have an even better year!

[tommy10]

Sidebum & Rance vs Pendles & Suckling
[/quote]
1st option for me. Sidebum is at a bargain price and may try and fit him in and Rance is quality. Two good premos.

[HotTiges]

prob been done before..

KK vs Bartel vs Laird vs Birch for a spot @ D3

[mattttwillll]

Best D2/3/4 for $505,000 and under..

I have Shaw, Bartel and Yeo   

Go another Premium or get a Mackenzie type cost and pocket the Cash?