Player X v Player Y

[Money Shot]

Goldy/Martin V Gawn ...
Does anyone think Gawn has a chance of being a top 2 ruckman?
I saw an article on the AFL website today which has me looking at him as a pod.

[GoLions]

Goldy/Martin V Gawn ...
Does anyone think Gawn has a chance of being a top 2 ruckman?
I saw an article on the AFL website today which has me looking at him as a pod.

Not even close. Goldy for #1 spot. Stefan/NicNat next 2. And tbh I'm not really looking at anyone else :P
Mummy will score well but probably won't last half the season. Jacobs could go alright, but without Danger HTAs could drop. Sandi will probably be up there, and that's about it for me.

[mattttwillll]

H.Shaw + J.Aish + $25,300 vs K.Simpson + S.Hurn

[fanTCfool]

H.Shaw + J.Aish + $25,300 vs K.Simpson + S.Hurn

Simmo + Hurn, but not so sure on Hurn

[mattttwillll]

H.Shaw + J.Aish + $25,300 vs K.Simpson + S.Hurn

Simmo + Hurn, but not so sure on Hurn

anyone else come into consideration below Hurn?

[GoLions]

H.Shaw + J.Aish + $25,300 vs K.Simpson + S.Hurn

Simmo + Hurn, but not so sure on Hurn

anyone else come into consideration below Hurn?

I don't mind the Hurn pick, should score well with Emac back

[supercoachhelp]

Based on how much profit they will generate and yearly averages

Hopper vs Polkinghorne

[fanTCfool]

Based on how much profit they will generate and yearly averages

Hopper vs Polkinghorne

Has to be Polkinghorne for now, no one has seen Hopper play at this level

[Big Mac]

Goldy/Martin V Gawn ...
Does anyone think Gawn has a chance of being a top 2 ruckman?
I saw an article on the AFL website today which has me looking at him as a pod.

I'd expect him to finish around ~4th for total points (i.e. slightly better than Jacobs and Sandi, and also assuming Mumford misses games)

Yes he is dominating match simulation at the moment but the Dees simply don't have anyone that can match him in the centre or around the ground

[_wato]

Smith > Birchall thoughts?

[mattttwillll]

Shaw + Aish and Westhoff       vs         Simpson, Yeo and Greene??

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Shaw + Aish and Westhoff       vs         Simpson, Yeo and Greene??

For me, option 1 hands down,in saying that fully expect everyone else to go option 2. I like Shaw and Westhoff a lot and expect Westy to explode early on. 

Which of these defenders makes way for Francis and some much needed cash ??    Lonergan, Aish,  Harwood  or D Howe

Backline ( going very cheap )   is  T McDonald,  J Lonergan,  R Harwood,  J Aish,  D Howe,  M Brown (ESS)  // N Broad,, K Collins   

;)  Expecting at least 7 of this 8 to line up for Rd 1. Hopefully that's not wishful thinking or the result of a mental wet-dream   8)

[GoLions]

Smith > Birchall thoughts?

I prefer Birchall myself

[H1bb3i2d]

Shaw + Aish and Westhoff       vs         Simpson, Yeo and Greene??

For me, option 1 hands down,in saying that fully expect everyone else to go option 2. I like Shaw and Westhoff a lot and expect Westy to explode early on. 

Which of these defenders makes way for Francis and some much needed cash ??    Lonergan, Aish,  Harwood  or D Howe

Backline ( going very cheap )   is  T McDonald,  J Lonergan,  R Harwood,  J Aish,  D Howe,  M Brown (ESS)  // N Broad,, K Collins   

;)  Expecting at least 7 of this 8 to line up for Rd 1. Hopefully that's not wishful thinking or the result of a mental wet-dream   8)

Don't think any of those 4, nor Francis, are best 22.

[GoLions]

Shaw + Aish and Westhoff       vs         Simpson, Yeo and Greene??

For me, option 1 hands down,in saying that fully expect everyone else to go option 2. I like Shaw and Westhoff a lot and expect Westy to explode early on. 

Which of these defenders makes way for Francis and some much needed cash ??    Lonergan, Aish,  Harwood  or D Howe

Backline ( going very cheap )   is  T McDonald,  J Lonergan,  R Harwood,  J Aish,  D Howe,  M Brown (ESS)  // N Broad,, K Collins   

;)  Expecting at least 7 of this 8 to line up for Rd 1. Hopefully that's not wishful thinking or the result of a mental wet-dream   8)

Don't think any of those 4, nor Francis, are best 22.

Are you referring to Lonergan, Harwood, Aish, and Howe? Harwood is at this point, Lonergan I would've thought would be, but don't think he's a great pick. Howe probably fighting with Lithers, and maybe ahead after last NAB game, but too expensive to make enough cash. And Aish I wouldn't have in Pies 22.