Player X v Player Y

[supercoachhelp]

Daisy or Bird

Avoid BOTH!

nah nah

Tex is right, avoid both

i don't have the money

Still avoid both       ;)

Ahhhh

[fanTCfool]

Daisy or Bird

Avoid BOTH!

nah nah

Tex is right, avoid both

i don't have the money

Still avoid both       ;)

Ahhhh

I'd say the public verdict has been pretty definitive

[AaronKirk]

Daisy or Bird

Avoid BOTH!

nah nah

Tex is right, avoid both

i don't have the money

Still avoid both       ;)

Ahhhh

I'd say the public verdict has been pretty definitive

If you have to pick between the 2 i'd say Daisy. He was alright the other night.

But I agree with the others.

[GoLions]

motlop vs mitch robbo

Mitch

[TexR74]

Scott Selwood vs another mid around his price, i think he could be a good POD mid pricer as opposed to O'Meara. He has had two 104+ seasons and Cats are expected to make the leap to Premiership contenders.

[H1bb3i2d]

Scott Selwood vs another mid around his price, i think he could be a good POD mid pricer as opposed to O'Meara. He has had two 104+ seasons and Cats are expected to make the leap to Premiership contenders.

I think we'd all be all over him if he wasn't coming back from ankle surgery and right to go round 1... But that's doubtful

[NickyBoy]

Danger, Birchall and M Brown (WCE) vs Wines, Broadie Smith and Harwood + $30,000

[Ringo]

No comparison Danger, Birchall and Brown - 2 players who will be in top 10 v Wines who may get there and Smith who could also push for Top 10. Harwood over Brown does not compensate for the difference in first 2.

[TexR74]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

[supercoachhelp]

Daisy or Bird

Avoid BOTH!

nah nah

Tex is right, avoid both

i don't have the money

Still avoid both       ;)

Ahhhh

I'd say the public verdict has been pretty definitive

If you have to pick between the 2 i'd say Daisy. He was alright the other night.

But I agree with the others.

who can i get for under $420k then

[GoLions]

Daisy or Bird

Avoid BOTH!

nah nah

Tex is right, avoid both

i don't have the money

Still avoid both       ;)

Ahhhh

I'd say the public verdict has been pretty definitive

If you have to pick between the 2 i'd say Daisy. He was alright the other night.

But I agree with the others.

who can i get for under $420k then

I'd probably prefer to go for either a rookie, or a Wells/Simpkin if you don't have them already (maybe Conca, Anderson, Bennedy?)

Or if you can get a bit more cash, about 25k more is Greene, and upwards from there guys like Billings, Buddy, both Lynch's, Smith, Bell

[GoLions]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

One or two? I wouldn't be that confident in starting Rampe or Yeo myself (although do like Yeo for DT perhaps)

[H1bb3i2d]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

Rampe < KK < Yeo < Birchall < Bartel

[fanTCfool]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

Rampe < KK < Yeo < Birchall < Bartel

Agree, but only just.

[TexR74]

Which one do i NOT pick?

Yeo vs Bartel vs KK vs Rampe vs Birchall

Rampe < KK < Yeo < Birchall < Bartel

I forget which way the arrows go haha is bartel or rampe first