Player X v Player Y

[quinny88]

Brodie Smith v Jimmy Bartel?

Bartel has proven time and time again that he can score enough for a premium defender. Smith has only done it once.

So Bartel easily for me.

I tend to agree but do age and the fact that he won't play midfield hurt him?

[ben_020285]

Brodie Smith v Jimmy Bartel?

Bartel has proven time and time again that he can score enough for a premium defender. Smith has only done it once.

So Bartel easily for me.

I tend to agree but do age and the fact that he won't play midfield hurt him?

I think they are both slight causes for concern. I'm not expecting him to average 120 like he has previously but I don't think a 100 average is out of the question even at his age and without time in the midfield.

[RaisyDaisy]

JPK vs Gray

[Footyrulz]

JPK vs Gray

JPK is more reliable in terms of averaging 105 and playing every game, but Gray is more fun to watch!
Gray is also discounted by 3 due to his injury game, and has more potential to average 115 (given Port's likely rise and a greater ability to score 130+).

[sidvicious]

James Aish vs Ryan Harwood

Also which two out of T.Greene Z.Merrett S.Motlop or Buddy

[GoLions]

James Aish vs Ryan Harwood

Also which two out of T.Greene Z.Merrett S.Motlop or Buddy

Aish wasn't best 22 at brisbane so I don't see him walking straight into the pies 22 tbh. Harwood probably a better scorer anyway if fit.

Buddy definitely best option of those forwards, maybe Greene second?

[frenzy]

James Aish vs Ryan Harwood

Also which two out of T.Greene Z.Merrett S.Motlop or Buddy

Aish wasn't best 22 at brisbane so I don't see him walking straight into the pies 22 tbh. Harwood probably a better scorer anyway if fit.

Buddy definitely best option of those forwards, maybe Greene second?

Was it form or injury that kept Harwood out last season only playing 3 games?

[GoLions]

James Aish vs Ryan Harwood

Also which two out of T.Greene Z.Merrett S.Motlop or Buddy

Aish wasn't best 22 at brisbane so I don't see him walking straight into the pies 22 tbh. Harwood probably a better scorer anyway if fit.

Buddy definitely best option of those forwards, maybe Greene second?

Was it form or injury that kept Harwood out last season only playing 3 games?

Mostly injury (and subsequently match fitness)

[_wato]

Gunston v Roughy

[TomK]

Gunston

[fasttrack13]

Gunston v Roughy

neither, but gunston if it has to be 1

James Aish vs Ryan Harwood

Also which two out of T.Greene Z.Merrett S.Motlop or Buddy

Aish for me, he basically declined to play for brisbane from what i heard. Might put in some effort at the pies.

and probably any of them but motlop... choose on byes + cash because theyll all go around the same!

JPK vs Gray

im going gray, new interchange cap will grant him extra time up forward! Could really hit the scoreboard!

[_wato]

Neither? Joking?

[GoLions]

They're both great, but only one is a GUN

[sidvicious]

Neither? Joking?

Roughead out of the two
but would prefer Josh j for constancy from a Kpf.

[MC]

Gunston v Roughy

With the new interchange cap I could see Rough rucking the forward half, adding some points possibly?
Both are safe for 90 i'd say, though there's more value elsewhere