Player X v Player Y

Started by ben_020285, December 22, 2015, 02:28:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sabretooth Tigers

 :)
Top call Goosey   ;)

Goosey


_wato

Dunno about Heeney ST, as a mid/forward he is surrounded by blokes at Sydney who are higher in the pecking order than him in terms of mid time and point scoring ability. JPK, Hanners, Parker, Jack, T Mitch, Mcveigh for example

Heeney at most could possibly hit 80 but I do not think he's worth it... Hate to say it too but second year blues as they say, may affect him

Sabretooth Tigers

Quote from: _wato on January 02, 2016, 12:27:35 AM
Dunno about Heeney ST, as a mid/forward he is surrounded by blokes at Sydney who are higher in the pecking order than him in terms of mid time and point scoring ability. JPK, Hanners, Parker, Jack, T Mitch, Mcveigh for example

Heeney at most could possibly hit 80 but I do not think he's worth it... Hate to say it too but second year blues as they say, may affect him

discounting prices who would be your first midfield pick from the Swans ??

_wato

Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on January 02, 2016, 12:38:35 AM
discounting prices who would be your first midfield pick from the Swans ??

Discounting prices?? That's a tough one but Kennedy > Hanners > Parker > Mitchell > Jack

Including prices would be Parker > Kennedy > Mitchell > Hannebery > Jack

sidvicious

#125
J.Polec vs D.Thomas vs J.O'Meara

_wato


Lions Man

Bennell v Dahl v Zorko put them in order.

I cant really decide on two so hopefully someone on here will help me out.


Money Shot

Bennell has the highest ceiling and could go around 110-120 easily and you don't want to miss out on that.
Dahl is 23 so should be heading into his prime although Libba might take a few points
Zorko scores pretty ordinary however with both of Beams and Rocky playing so he would come last for me.


Peter

Dalhouse vs Rioli vs Martin - i need two of, please

Money Shot

Quote from: Peter on January 02, 2016, 01:13:17 PM
Dalhouse vs Rioli vs Martin - i need two of, please
Martin is a lock so get him in.
Dahl is a safer pick who could score better than Rioli as well but Rioli only needs 10-15 disposals a game and he will be averaging 100-100.
I would pick Dahl and Martin as they are just so much safer than Cyril.

GraysFan

Wines/Swallow + Goldy vs Dusty + Pendles?

GraysFan

Quote from: Peter on January 02, 2016, 01:13:17 PM
Dalhouse vs Rioli vs Martin - i need two of, please

Martin > Dalhouse > Rioli

enzedder

Quote from: Lions Man on January 02, 2016, 11:59:03 AM
Bennell v Dahl v Zorko put them in order.
Dahl...Bennell...Zorko
Quote from: Peter on January 02, 2016, 01:13:17 PM
Dalhouse vs Rioli vs Martin - i need two of, please
Martin and Dahlhaus

MC

Quote from: GraysFan on January 02, 2016, 01:44:28 PM
Wines/Swallow + Goldy vs Dusty + Pendles?

Dusty + Pendles for me, both are premium/keepers and both are capable of being top 3 in their respective positions, whereas Wines/Swallow are not.