Player X v Player Y

[Big Mac]

Pendles v Sloane/Selwood

Is Pendles worth the extra money if he is going to play more of a forward role this season?

I really can't see this 'forward role' being that big of a deal

He is still almost guaranteed to be an elite scorer this year

I'd go with Pendles

[Money Shot]

Bennell v Dahlhous.

[Southstorm]

Bennell

[GraysFan]

Pendlebury vs Beams?

[Grufflez]

Pendles v Sloane/Selwood

Is Pendles worth the extra money if he is going to play more of a forward role this season?

I really can't see this 'forward role' being that big of a deal

He is still almost guaranteed to be an elite scorer this year

I'd go with Pendles

Do you mean sweeping backmen? i have not yet seen anything about him playing forward? even when he rests u would expect back not forward? fill me in please  :)

[Money Shot]

Pendles v Sloane/Selwood

Is Pendles worth the extra money if he is going to play more of a forward role this season?

I really can't see this 'forward role' being that big of a deal

He is still almost guaranteed to be an elite scorer this year

I'd go with Pendles

Do you mean sweeping backmen? i have not yet seen anything about him playing forward? even when he rests u would expect back not forward? fill me in please  :)

I read it in the Collingwood forum and they would have a pretty good idea of it I reckon!

[GoLions]

Pendles v Sloane/Selwood

Is Pendles worth the extra money if he is going to play more of a forward role this season?

I really can't see this 'forward role' being that big of a deal

He is still almost guaranteed to be an elite scorer this year

I'd go with Pendles

Do you mean sweeping backmen? i have not yet seen anything about him playing forward? even when he rests u would expect back not forward? fill me in please  :)

I read it in the Collingwood forum and they would have a pretty good idea of it I reckon!

Pendles can be very damaging when he plays forward

[GoLions]

And FWIW I'd say Sloane, Beams, Jelwood are all slightly better value for money than Pendles is, and all should be around that top 8-10 range in the midfield by the end of the season. Personally I see Pendles and Jelwood as upgrade targets myself though. Just can't fit them in when you also have guys like Gaz, Rocky, Libba, Crouch, and JOM

[enzedder]

Bennell v Dahlhous.

Dahlhaus but I like both

Pendlebury vs Beams?

Beams but I like both

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :-\

Three will stay but one must go, but which one  ??

K Kolodjashnij     J Bartel     B Smith     P Seedsman

I can put up cases for and against all of them equally but keep coming back to one sticking point.
That is Bartel's age. Am I making too much of it guys ??   ??
                                                                                         :(

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Bennell v Dahlhous.

Dahlhaus but I like both

Pendlebury vs Beams?

Beams but I like both

If he stays straight, Bennell by the length of the Australian shoreline.   Out of Pendles and Beams,
whichever one you best afford first and then the other next

[Sabretooth Tigers]

And FWIW I'd say Sloane, Beams, Jelwood are all slightly better value for money than Pendles is, and all should be around that top 8-10 range in the midfield by the end of the season. Personally I see Pendles and Jelwood as upgrade targets myself though. Just can't fit them in when you also have guys like Gaz, Rocky, Libba, Crouch, and JOM

Hi GL, just a little curious on how you rate JOM.  So if he were not named Rd.1 but certain to definitely
line up in Rds,2 or 3 would you select him  ??

[MC]

:-\

Three will stay but one must go, but which one  ??

K Kolodjashnij     J Bartel     B Smith     P Seedsman

I can put up cases for and against all of them equally but keep coming back to one sticking point.
That is Bartel's age. Am I making too much of it guys ??   ??
                                                                                         :(

Very tough call! Smith seems the lock from the 4 I think. So 2 of Jimmy/Seeds/Kk...

I think I would go Smith, KK and Jimmy from those if cash is no worry. Seeds is great value but too many question marks at this stage.

[GoLions]

And FWIW I'd say Sloane, Beams, Jelwood are all slightly better value for money than Pendles is, and all should be around that top 8-10 range in the midfield by the end of the season. Personally I see Pendles and Jelwood as upgrade targets myself though. Just can't fit them in when you also have guys like Gaz, Rocky, Libba, Crouch, and JOM

Hi GL, just a little curious on how you rate JOM.  So if he were not named Rd.1 but certain to definitely
line up in Rds,2 or 3 would you select him  ??

I don't plan on starting him atm, but he should still be great value nonetheless

Currently looking at a starting midfield of Gaz, Rocky, Sloaney, Beams, Libba, Crouch, rookies. But also want Myers so we'll see what happens haha

[ben_020285]

I still can't decide between T.Mitch vs Shiel !

Shiel