Player X v Player Y

[ben_020285]

I really want to lock him in but he is way to injury prone for me. I don't have Leuy at this stage and there fore are not taking the risk.
Nic Nat and Martin for me.

Bartel V Simpson.

Bartel. I think he will average close to 100 and up until last year he has proved to be very durable. Cats rarely rest their older players as we've seen with Enright.

I think Simpson will average closer to 90.

[Ringo]

One I am agonising a little bit over Dahlhaus v Zorko.

Will Dahlhaus mid time suffer with Libbas return.  Conversely will Zorko get the same mid time at brisbane with a fully fit Brisbane midfield.  Think both will slip a little for this reason but who will slip further.

[Money Shot]

One I am agonising a little bit over Dahlhaus v Zorko.

Will Dahlhaus mid time suffer with Libbas return.  Conversely will Zorko get the same mid time at brisbane with a fully fit Brisbane midfield.  Think both will slip a little for this reason but who will slip further.

I like Dahl more. Think Libba will take a few points but he's natural improvement will gain a few. I think he will average around the same. Zorko wouldn't be a bad pick either though. I just think that with all the mids Brisbane have I don't see him getting as much time. It is really a tough one but don't think you could go wrong with either.

[ben_020285]

One I am agonising a little bit over Dahlhaus v Zorko.

Will Dahlhaus mid time suffer with Libbas return.  Conversely will Zorko get the same mid time at brisbane with a fully fit Brisbane midfield.  Think both will slip a little for this reason but who will slip further.

Zorko doesn't score well with both Rockliff and Beams in the same team with him. I don't think Libba returning will have too much of an effect on Dahlhaus' scoring.

Dahlhaus easily for me unless one of Rocky or Beams gets an LTI between now and the start of the season.

[MC]

I agree with Dahlhaus, though my reason is that I think Libba has more of an effect on the SC points of Picken and Wallis than Dahl. 

[_wato]

Matthew Boyd v Jarrad Mcveigh

&&&&& Rance v anyone under $523k (Simpson, Birch, Hurley, Laird) etc

[Money Shot]

Matthew Boyd v Jarrad Mcveigh

&&&&& Rance v anyone under $523k (Simpson, Birch, Hurley, Laird) etc

Mcveigh

Enright 8) I think he has been a great scorer for years now.

[ben_020285]

Matthew Boyd v Jarrad Mcveigh

&&&&& Rance v anyone under $523k (Simpson, Birch, Hurley, Laird) etc

McVeigh. I think Boyd's scoring output will drop a bit and he will get rested from time to time.

K Kolodjashnij. The returning GC mids won't have any effect on his scoring as he plays as a rebounding defender. Will average close to 100.

[ronl]

Agree, Ben.  I have had KK pencilled in since the middle of last year, this will be his breakout year.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

MvVeigh   and Hurley in a year where he starts to play like a hot Brian Lake.     ;)

[crowls]

Matthew Boyd v Jarrad Mcveigh

&&&&& Rance v anyone under $523k (Simpson, Birch, Hurley, Laird) etc

McVeigh. I think Boyd's scoring output will drop a bit and he will get rested from time to time.

K Kolodjashnij. The returning GC mids won't have any effect on his scoring as he plays as a rebounding defender. Will average close to 100.

Agree KK capable of improving again this year.   Could be a good POD.     McVeigh over Boyd.   Of others only Simpson I would consider.

[fasttrack13]

One I am agonising a little bit over Dahlhaus v Zorko.

Will Dahlhaus mid time suffer with Libbas return.  Conversely will Zorko get the same mid time at brisbane with a fully fit Brisbane midfield.  Think both will slip a little for this reason but who will slip further.

I think Dahlhaus got more midfield time upon the departure of griffen rather than libba being out... It was more mitch wallis who benefited greatly imo. Probably would prefer dahlhaus but zorko is a chance for improved midfield time now that redden is gone. So it's pretty even. they both should average around 100 give or take a few points.

Matthew Boyd v Jarrad Mcveigh

&&&&& Rance v anyone under $523k (Simpson, Birch, Hurley, Laird) etc

I dont really like either even though theyre top 5 defenders youll get them much cheaper. Would go Mcveigh though

Definitely not rance... KPB nonono.
Id go yeo/macmillan or bartel for uner 523k theyre all 90-105 players for me.

[fasttrack13]

Luke Parker v Dylan Shiel

[MC]

Luke Parker v Dylan Shiel

Both seem too risky to start with given all of the value mids around.

If the choice for SC draft was there i'd go with Parker by a nose because of his 108 season in 2014 and because Shiel will probably get more opposition attention in the absence of Treloar. 

[Gigantor]

Sidebottom vs Sloane  (Already have Rocky, don't want Jelwood)