Player X v Player Y

[eaglesman]

I think Martin is definitely a better option...
Lions now have a beautifully built midfield with players who know how to rove the ball and i think a full pre season of practise roving to martin i think his HO adv. % will rise 5-10% in addition to his possessions.
However nicnat as was said is 37k cheaper and as I'm strapped for cash i have him in right now. I think NN is set for a major breakout year so taking price and points into account its pretty even. If your not worried about cash Martin is the man.


Have one of my own:
Z.Merrett v T.Greene

For Me Greene easily

[eaglesman]

On the assumption you can only fit in one

Jelwood vs Sloane

Sloane easily

[eaglesman]

Lids vs Martin, of both?

I prefer lids but I suspect the saving of money will force me to pick dusty

[Grufflez]

I have 2 :o

Titch vs Shiel
Houli vs Rance

[eaglesman]

Barlow or Lids?
Some people have good arguments for both sides so I would like to see everyone else's thoughts!

Lids by a street

I am off Barlow though and there is absolutely no hope of him getting a gig in my side

[eaglesman]

Hibberd v Birchall
I know a lot of you would pick neither but just for arguments sake pick one!

Right now whoever cheaper but preseason form is the real decider for
Me

[GoLions]

I have 2 :o

Titch vs Shiel
Houli vs Rance

Shiel, Rance

[ben_020285]

Parker v Wines

Both underpriced due to injury affected seasons in 2015. Who is the better pick though and why?

[Money Shot]

Parker v Wines

Both underpriced due to injury affected seasons in 2015. Who is the better pick though and why?

I like Parker. Wines started to get tagged last season which dropped his scores a lot where as Parker wont get tagged as much with guys like Kennedy on the team.

[Money Shot]

Hibberd and Yeo v McVeigh and Seedsman

[fasttrack13]

Hibberd and Yeo v McVeigh and Seedsman

McVeigh + Seedsman definitely, it it was anyone but Hibberd then I'd go with the Yeo option, I personally like Rich.

Parker v Wines

Both underpriced due to injury affected seasons in 2015. Who is the better pick though and why?

Wines can't handle the tag yet Shiel has had 2 years to deal with it and has improved both years. Expect him to do the same again! So Shiel for me.

[ben_020285]

Hibberd and Yeo v McVeigh and Seedsman

McVeigh + Seedsman definitely, it it was anyone but Hibberd then I'd go with the Yeo option, I personally like Rich.

Parker v Wines

Both underpriced due to injury affected seasons in 2015. Who is the better pick though and why?

Wines can't handle the tag yet Shiel has had 2 years to deal with it and has improved both years. Expect him to do the same again! So Shiel for me.

Shiel could be a good pick too mate but was wondering about Parker v Wines  ;)

[GraysFan]

Hibberd and Yeo v McVeigh and Seedsman

McVeigh + Seedsman definitely, it it was anyone but Hibberd then I'd go with the Yeo option, I personally like Rich.

Parker v Wines

Both underpriced due to injury affected seasons in 2015. Who is the better pick though and why?

Wines can't handle the tag yet Shiel has had 2 years to deal with it and has improved both years. Expect him to do the same again! So Shiel for me.

Shiel could be a good pick too mate but was wondering about Parker v Wines  ;)

Id still go Shiel ;)
Nah, out of the 2 i would go Wines. Will probably improve along with Port this year and Gray/Boak are ahead of him in terms of being tagged.

Im still stuck on Nicnat vs Bennell (Via Burger). Pros and cons would be fantastic!

[The_Captain]

Travis Cloke V a can of Coke ?

[Money Shot]

Travis Cloke V a can of Coke ?

A can of coke consistently delivers week in week out where we Travis Cloke is too up and down for me.