Player X v Player Y

[Grufflez]

Martin, could score as well as lids this year and  will play more games.

[Ricochet]

I actually think Lids will have a better year but Dusty is probably safer

[Holz]

Alex Neal Buleen + Fyfe

v

Alex Rance + David Myers

[fasttrack13]

Alex Neal Buleen + Fyfe

v

Alex Rance + David Myers

Rance + Myers for me, even though I don't like Rance. I can see Myers making you 170-190k and scoring pretty well for you to upgrade him for not much to a fallen premo. Would consider someone else for Rance though.

[Ricochet]

Alex Neal Buleen + Fyfe

v

Alex Rance + David Myers

Rookie + Fyfe

[BomberSam]

Alex Neal Buleen + Fyfe

v

Alex Rance + David Myers

Rookie + Fyfe

+1

[meow meow]

Have one of my own:
Z.Merrett v T.Greene

Neither but Merrett if you have to have one. Steele and Hopper will take Treloar's inside mid spot and Toby will be stuck playing the same role as in 2015.

On the assumption you can only fit in one

Jelwood vs Sloane

Never start with Selwood. He always has a major dip at some point then storms home.

[Money Shot]

Barlow or Lids?
Some people have good arguments for both sides so I would like to see everyone else's thoughts!

[Holz]

Barlow or Lids?
Some people have good arguments for both sides so I would like to see everyone else's thoughts!

easy

Barlow

cheaper and doesnt have these niggling injuries that lids seems to have going at the moment.

[Money Shot]

Barlow or Lids?
Some people have good arguments for both sides so I would like to see everyone else's thoughts!

easy

Barlow

cheaper and doesnt have these niggling injuries that lids seems to have going at the moment.

The argument is what if Barlow doesn't improve and keeps playing out of position?

[Ringo]

So you have to balance that against Lids injuries.

[Money Shot]

So you have to balance that against Lids injuries.

That's true! 600k for an injury prone player isn't worth it unless he's name is Gary.

[Money Shot]

Hibberd v Birchall
I know a lot of you would pick neither but just for arguments sake pick one!

[TomK]

Probably Birchall

[Gigantor]

Hibberd v Birchall
I know a lot of you would pick neither but just for arguments sake pick one!

Hibberd, he has an upside, could potentially increase his average by 10ppg

But I don't seeing Birchall going up by more tha 2-3 ppg