Player X v Player Y

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

Keep which 3 out of  Wells,  J Lyons,  J Anderson and L Duggan.  ??   Or burst a boiler to keep all 4 ??

[fanTCfool]

:)

Keep which 3 out of  Wells,  J Lyons,  J Anderson and L Duggan.  ??   Or burst a boiler to keep all 4 ??

Biased for Lyons but he is certainly worth keeping from those 3, hopefully he is a starter for the Crows
Duggan is a good prospect but probably not starting 22
Don't like Wells much but would start him
Anderson doesn't appeal much either, but probable starter for the Roos so I'd take him over Duggan assuming Duggan is in the Eagles' best 22

[Sabretooth Tigers]

:)

Keep which 3 out of  Wells,  J Lyons,  J Anderson and L Duggan.  ??   Or burst a boiler to keep all 4 ??

Biased for Lyons but he is certainly worth keeping from those 3, hopefully he is a starter for the Crows
Duggan is a good prospect but probably not starting 22
Don't like Wells much but would start him
Anderson doesn't appeal much either, but probable starter for the Roos so I'd take him over Duggan assuming Duggan is in the Eagles' best 22

Totally agree with Lyons but after that things get a bit foggy for me. Thanks for the opinion mate.     ???

[fanTCfool]

:)

Keep which 3 out of  Wells,  J Lyons,  J Anderson and L Duggan.  ??   Or burst a boiler to keep all 4 ??

Biased for Lyons but he is certainly worth keeping from those 3, hopefully he is a starter for the Crows
Duggan is a good prospect but probably not starting 22
Don't like Wells much but would start him
Anderson doesn't appeal much either, but probable starter for the Roos so I'd take him over Duggan assuming Duggan is in the Eagles' best 22

Totally agree with Lyons but after that things get a bit foggy for me. Thanks for the opinion mate.     ???

Does get a little sloppy, good luck with it!

[fasttrack13]

:)

Keep which 3 out of  Wells,  J Lyons,  J Anderson and L Duggan.  ??   Or burst a boiler to keep all 4 ??

Biased for Lyons but he is certainly worth keeping from those 3, hopefully he is a starter for the Crows
Duggan is a good prospect but probably not starting 22
Don't like Wells much but would start him
Anderson doesn't appeal much either, but probable starter for the Roos so I'd take him over Duggan assuming Duggan is in the Eagles' best 22

Duggan had cemented his spot until he got injured

"Midway through last season, the West Coast youngster had established himself â€" both in the team and as a star of the future â€" before a posterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee in July prematurely ended his campaign."

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/teams/west-coast/west-coast-eagles-youngster-liam-duggan-says-he-can-take-plenty-from-2015-despite-injury-blow/news-story/91447a20f09dcc420c0ed475774d96b4

[The_Captain]

Duggan is 100% in Eagles best 22. He has one of the best foot skills. Simo loves him. He's in top 20 selected for sure last year. Into second year so should be even better now and be even more certain of a starter. Just his scoring you need to worry about. Will up his average to 70-75 I reckon.

[auscoyote]

Parker or Bont

[fasttrack13]

Parker or Bont

Pretty even... Parker will get better under a tag this year or it'll leave him and hanners will attract it I expect 105-110. Bont is however a freakish talent as we all know and has the potential to do what Selwood, Fyfe, Rockliff etc... Have done before him and breakout early in his career. It's too even for me a. Because there's risk in both b. There's upside in both.

[auscoyote]

Parker or Bont

Pretty even... Parker will get better under a tag this year or it'll leave him and hanners will attract it I expect 105-110. Bont is however a freakish talent as we all know and has the potential to do what Selwood, Fyfe, Rockliff etc... Have done before him and breakout early in his career. It's too even for me a. Because there's risk in both b. There's upside in both.

Haha, my thoughts exactly. That's why i posed the question.

The unknown is the libba effect, who will get the tag at the doggies and who will get off the leash.
It should be Bonts breakout year or he should at least increase his average by at least 5 i would imagine.

With the capped rotations, mids who can kick goals resting fwd will be a factor imo. Parker has him pipped there but if Bont breaks out than he should have the bigger upside.

I cant split them either :-\

[Hawker_08]

Parker or Bont

Personally rate Wines over both of them

[auscoyote]

Parker or Bont

Personally rate Wines over both of them

Already have wines at M5 ;)

[Hawker_08]

Parker or Bont

Personally rate Wines over both of them

Already have wines at M5 ;)

Lovely haha. Well in that case then if you could Ward would be my choice but if you don't have the money then I would opt for Parker.

[fanTCfool]

Sloane vs Wines

Bump because I need an opinion or two

[GoLions]

Sloane vs Wines

Bump because I need an opinion or two

Sloaneyyyyy

[fasttrack13]

Sloane vs Wines

Bump because I need an opinion or two

I have both... But Sloane gets the w, I think he will go huge