Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Colty]

If tucker pus out  a decent score he will hold his spot . Big if though.

[LordSneeze]

If tucker pus out  a decent score he will hold his spot . Big if though.

His score doesn't mean anything to whether he will hold his spot. Its all about whether he performs the role he is asked to at the level required.
He might get a 70 and get dropped because he didn't play his role, or he might score 30 and hold his spot because he played the way they wanted him too.

[MontyJnr]

Tucker is such a big risk. I need someone that is going to play across the byes.

Although it is another big risk going early on Collins, then early on Trengove round 12 and hoping someone else is available before round 13. Jansen? Who knows :-\

[Raiden]

Tucker is such a big risk. I need someone that is going to play across the byes.

Although it is another big risk going early on Collins, then early on Trengove round 12 and hoping someone else is available before round 13. Jansen? Who knows :-\

Yeah i'm taking the risk & going 1 week early on Collins, gonna pass on Tucker - Surely Collins has the better JS & should hold his spot in Def.

[sammy123]

any hawks supporters got info on stewart?

trengrove did okay for his 1st game back

[RaisyDaisy]

Stewart and Jansen both with 90+ on debut

I had Jansen in my Rd1 side as a placeholder so have been waiting for him to finally come, but his RD15 bye is a massive turnoff

Stewart on the other hand - can we trust Clarko to give him enough games? I don't think we can

[Gigantor]

Stewart and Jansen both with 90+ on debut

I had Jansen in my Rd1 side as a placeholder so have been waiting for him to finally come, but his RD15 bye is a massive turnoff

Stewart on the other hand - can we trust Clarko to give him enough games? I don't think we can

Totally agree with this, Rd 15 is a killer for Jansen

I would take a punt on Stewart if I didn't already have Brand  :-[

[fanTCfool]

Tempted to go Smith to Jansen this week and get another premo in.

[RaisyDaisy]

Tempted to go Smith to Jansen this week and get another premo in.

Honestly, before this round even started I was already considering going a week early on Smith/Davis to Jansen next week

I know his bye doesn't help me one bit, but I rate him and would have started him from Rd1

Not expecting 90+ every week, but I do believe he will hold his spot all year as long as he plays well so could be handy bench cover

I passed on both Keays and Matho, as I wanted Jansen of those 3

[MontyJnr]

I'm tempted to go Selwood to Jansen ::)

[RaisyDaisy]

Hopper is RD15 and seems to be going down every week since that cracking debut

Hopper to Jansen would work, being the same bye and can bank a nice stash of cash on that too

Yeah, that might be the play

[Raiden]

I'm tempted to go Selwood to Jansen ::)

So am i, or Stewart!

[Raiden]

So now Stewart, Trengrove & Jansen all come into the mix.

[MontyJnr]

So now Stewart, Trengrove & Jansen all come into the mix.

Perfect timing for the 3 trade week we get in Round 13 :)

[RaisyDaisy]

Can't see myself getting Stewart, but 2 of Hopper/Davis/Smith will be double downed to Treng and Jansen