Rookie discussions and when to cash

[fanTCfool]

Are there any forward rookies coming through soon?

Dougal Howard on the bubble this week, whether you go there or not is up to you.

[Ricochet]

Not going to touch anymore Freo players, only Neale is worth it.

D.Tucker has left me in a massive jam looking like he will not get another opportunity

He'll be back mate. He came in off two weeks of not playing at all. Ross just didnt want him playing AFL getting limited touches and falling into a slump. He's a magnet so sent him back to find the footy and some form.

[Grufflez]

Not going to touch anymore Freo players, only Neale is worth it.

D.Tucker has left me in a massive jam looking like he will not get another opportunity

He'll be back mate. He came in off two weeks of not playing at all. Ross just didnt want him playing AFL getting limited touches and falling into a slump. He's a magnet so sent him back to find the footy and some form.

Thanks Ricochet, really eases my mind knowing that, i'll hold him then.
Much appreciated.

[Holz]

the plan was amthieson this week
collins the next
then ????

is getting howard an option? I would want him to play through byes.
then i can get math on the buble
collins on the bubble

[RaisyDaisy]

the plan was amthieson this week
collins the next
then ????

is getting howard an option? I would want him to play through byes.
then i can get math on the buble
collins on the bubble

I just dont rate Howard and Williams JS and scoring ability so passing on both

Hopper this week, Matho next week and Collins the week after

Might even grab Collins with Matho next week

[Holz]

the plan was amthieson this week
collins the next
then ????

is getting howard an option? I would want him to play through byes.
then i can get math on the buble
collins on the bubble

I just dont rate Howard and Williams JS and scoring ability so passing on both

Hopper this week, Matho next week and Collins the week after

Might even grab Collins with Matho next week

Jonas out for 6 weeks.

Trengove i think has to go down the backline.
Lobbe is injured.
Who will ruck for them?

I cant afford hopper or i would get him. Getting howard means i get matho and collins on the buble instead of after 1 game. thats risky plus it means i need someone in 2 weeks or might be forced to get a dount.

[Maca24]

Anyone considering Mackenzie Willis if he can score better this week?
Will be on the bubble and provides a handy DPP link.

[Rusty00]

the plan was amthieson this week
collins the next
then ????

is getting howard an option? I would want him to play through byes.
then i can get math on the buble
collins on the bubble

I just dont rate Howard and Williams JS and scoring ability so passing on both

Hopper this week, Matho next week and Collins the week after

Might even grab Collins with Matho next week

Jonas out for 6 weeks.

Trengove i think has to go down the backline.
Lobbe is injured.
Who will ruck for them?

I cant afford hopper or i would get him. Getting howard means i get matho and collins on the buble instead of after 1 game. thats risky plus it means i need someone in 2 weeks or might be forced to get a dount.

Perhaps for this week, but Carlile is also waiting in the wings to come back. I would think against teams with lesser rucks (eg. Collingwood in Rd.11, Bulldogs in Rd.12) that they would prefer to go with the Trengove rucking option.

Of course if Dougal comes out and plays really well this week, that would change things ;)

[RaisyDaisy]

Yep Carlisle will be back very soon

Also what I don't like about Howard is that the 2 games he has played, he played a game then got dropped, then came back for one game and got dropped again

I've already got Dunkley and now Brand - can't afford to carry another spud

[Raiden]

Yep Carlisle will be back very soon

Also what I don't like about Howard is that the 2 games he has played, he played a game then got dropped, then came back for one game and got dropped again

I've already got Dunkley and now Brand - can't afford to carry another spud

Yeah i also have Brand & Dunkley - Praying that Dunkley makes the final cut, doubt it thou...

[steven3]

Anyone considering Oscar McDonald over Williams. I need a def rookie and even though his a little more expensive, shouldn't his JS be better? Named rd 1 over Dunn and got injured but has come back in without Dunn getting a run. Looks like they want to develop him for the future. Thoughts?

[Marcon]

Right now leaning towards holding DBJ and ditching Brown. Both about on a par JS wise, however I much prefer fielding DBJ than Brown, even if it is at the expense of 20-30k.

[shaker]

Right now leaning towards holding DBJ and ditching Brown. Both about on a par JS wise, however I much prefer fielding DBJ than Brown, even if it is at the expense of 20-30k.

I'm getting rid of both this week both are ready to cull think they are about as fat as they will get

[Grufflez]

I ended up upgrading Hartley and holding DBJ, willing to take a short term loss of 10-20k in hopes 1. he plays a lot 2.he may have another good game and start rising again.

[PICCOLLO]

Isnt there talk DBJ may be a late out?

That said, he is a better scorer than hartley.