Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Bully]

Rocky is 2/3 weeks away so suspect one of Keays or Matthieson will make way.  Will depend on form at the time and the beast really stepped up on Saturday.  Selectors may drop another though if performances are not up to scratch.

I more than likely will be getting Mattho next week if that helps,

rocky 2-3 weeks away. but how long will he last on field? surely a week or 2 in reserves? just for match fitness

If it's 3 weeks then I may have to ditch him, trying hard to hang on however.

[frenzy]

some debutants this week would be nice.   ???

[RaisyDaisy]

Rico or anyone else

So with Pearce now gone, does Sam Collins or Tucker get a proper shot now?

[Judd Magic]

Rico or anyone else

So with Pearce now gone, does Sam Collins or Tucker get a proper shot now?

Collins would be the like for like replacement for Pearce RD.

Doubt Tucker comes back anytime soon to be honest.

[Big Mac]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??

He has none

He is just getting a taste for the level, Dunn easily ahead of him at this stage and Frost should be too now that he has moved back into defence

[PICCOLLO]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??

He has none

He is just getting a taste for the level, Dunn easily ahead of him at this stage and Frost should be too now that he has moved back into defence

I think his JS could be better than that. Was started r1 ahead of the likes of Dunn before he got injured and has been brought back in pretty quickly.

[Big Mac]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??

He has none

He is just getting a taste for the level, Dunn easily ahead of him at this stage and Frost should be too now that he has moved back into defence

I think his JS could be better than that. Was started r1 ahead of the likes of Dunn before he got injured and has been brought back in pretty quickly.

Have you watched either game?

[King_Robbo]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??

He has none

He is just getting a taste for the level, Dunn easily ahead of him at this stage and Frost should be too now that he has moved back into defence

I think his JS could be better than that. Was started r1 ahead of the likes of Dunn before he got injured and has been brought back in pretty quickly.

Have you watched either game?

Williams will make way for Adams and Boyd. Then Suckling is back next week..

[RaisyDaisy]

Suckers and Boyd back this week

I wouldn't touch either Williams or Omac

[Raiden]

Suckers and Boyd back this week

I wouldn't touch either Williams or Omac

Yeah i seen Bevo mention that however still nothing on Adams which is a worry, definitely wouldn't be grabbing Williams thou.

[Holz]

I know guys are on the bubble but ill pick up collins before any of them. For the record im avoiding collins and going a week early on mathieson instead but if i had to collins is the guy. Wont score big but should be cover.

[RaisyDaisy]

I know guys are on the bubble but ill pick up collins before any of them. For the record im avoiding collins and going a week early on mathieson instead but if i had to collins is the guy. Wont score big but should be cover.

Just to clarify you're talking about Freo Sam Collins, and not WB Kieren Collins right?

If Sam Collins gets named I'll grab him soon and he can sit on the bench. Won't be touching any dog rookies

[Big Mac]

Viv seemed to do alright in the parts of the game I saw.

Yeh he did okay, but he needs to do better than okay when we have 3 best 22 players to come back in and guys racking up 30 in the VFL every week

[Holz]

I know guys are on the bubble but ill pick up collins before any of them. For the record im avoiding collins and going a week early on mathieson instead but if i had to collins is the guy. Wont score big but should be cover.

Just to clarify you're talking about Freo Sam Collins, and not WB Kieren Collins right?

If Sam Collins gets named I'll grab him soon and he can sit on the bench. Won't be touching any dog rookies

sorry yes Sam Collins.

he should get named for Pearce nad since they are blodding youngsters and not playing guys like barlow there is no way he shouldnt play.

this is his WAFl stats

11.8 kicks 4.9 handballs 7.2 marks 1.7 tackles

thats 73.6 DT a game. If he can put up 45-50 DT a game ill be stoked as i reckon he would have a good SC to DT ratio like most key defenders.

[PICCOLLO]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??

He has none

He is just getting a taste for the level, Dunn easily ahead of him at this stage and Frost should be too now that he has moved back into defence

I think his JS could be better than that. Was started r1 ahead of the likes of Dunn before he got injured and has been brought back in pretty quickly.

Have you watched either game?

That bad huh?