Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Gigantor]

Not interested in Paine, rd 15 bye is a killer since I plan on getting in Hopper and Mathieson next week

Plus I'm wary of his JS and scoring potential.

[RaisyDaisy]

Only looking at Paine because I'm desperate for a fwd rookie downgrade option

Redman is only 131k but scores like shower - but I guess having DPP does give flexibility  :-\

[Ringo]

Rocky is 2/3 weeks away so suspect one of Keays or Matthieson will make way.  Will depend on form at the time and the beast really stepped up on Saturday.  Selectors may drop another though if performances are not up to scratch.

I more than likely will be getting Mattho next week if that helps,

[sammy123]

Rocky is 2/3 weeks away so suspect one of Keays or Matthieson will make way.  Will depend on form at the time and the beast really stepped up on Saturday.  Selectors may drop another though if performances are not up to scratch.

I more than likely will be getting Mattho next week if that helps,

rocky 2-3 weeks away. but how long will he last on field? surely a week or 2 in reserves? just for match fitness

[Big Mac]

Would be keen to see how Mathieson scores when he isn't ducking his head at every opportunity

[Ringo]

Would be keen to see how Mathieson scores when he isn't ducking his head at every opportunity

It is bull at a gate attitude in going for the ball and if that gets him free kicks so be it.  But seriously though his attack on the ball is what will gain him SC points. Only real worry for me with him, and I cringed a couple of times on Sunday. is he is coming back after a broken jaw and he grabbed at it a couple of times after the hits.

[Big Mac]

Who goes out for those 3?

Could just about raffle it between Newton, Michie, ANB and O'mac

Oliver probably also a low chance for a rest given the 6-day turn around and the corkie he copped, Hunt a possible out too

[Nige]

Viv seemed to do alright in the parts of the game I saw.

[mzunguman]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

[Blues Blues Blues]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

I'm pondering the same question. I need a downgrade this week in the backline.

[MontyJnr]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Williams isn't a KPD. Adams is a KPD. Adams would take Collins' spot you'd think.

Boyd or Suckling could push Williams out.

[wetDT]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

[jfitty]

I think he'll hold his spot until Suckling is back..

The Dogs supporters on BigFooty seem to rate him quite a bit (take that as you will) so he could keep his place until a few more players return

I'll be picking him up if he is named, his price and DDP make him fairly enticing

[PICCOLLO]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

[mzunguman]

Is Williams worth a downgrade or does Adams take his spot??

Im looking at williams as well, or maybe mcdonald?

Mcdonald for me.

What's his js like??