Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Ringo]

Richmond supporters who gets drops first Menadue or Short - Short is on the bubble this week and gives a downgrade option if named. Menadue is a positive B/e so just wondering who has the better JS or are both shaky.

[bottlemart]

Is Dunkley any chance of returning to the Bulldogs line up.  Does anyone know how he went in the VFL.

[sammy123]

Richmond supporters who gets drops first Menadue or Short - Short is on the bubble this week and gives a downgrade option if named. Menadue is a positive B/e so just wondering who has the better JS or are both shaky.

menadue still had 18 touches last week against crows. hardwick might have been happy with that as least he was getting his hands on the ball

[Goosey]

Richmond supporters who gets drops first Menadue or Short - Short is on the bubble this week and gives a downgrade option if named. Menadue is a positive B/e so just wondering who has the better JS or are both shaky.

menadue still had 18 touches last week against crows. hardwick might have been happy with that as least he was getting his hands on the ball

Slow start, but finished well, hopefully he keeps his spot.

[Bully]

Richmond supporters who gets drops first Menadue or Short - Short is on the bubble this week and gives a downgrade option if named. Menadue is a positive B/e so just wondering who has the better JS or are both shaky.

Think both will survive but Menadue started to resemble a deer in the headlights, too afraid to make a mistake. 7 clangers for the night is an ominous sign, will survive due to a flat deck in Perth but he'll need a top game to hold his spot.

[sammy123]

no pertracca this week. have to wait another week for him

[ivolve]

Does anyone have an update on Darcey Macpherson from the Gold Coast, heard big things preseason and Avg 61 in NAB.

On the rookie list

They might be regretting that now, R.Davis has looked pretty average in my eyes so far, i hope the guy continues to improve
and makes the most out of it but just sayin'.

Can anyone give me Milera's break even and projected price increase please, would be most helpful, cheers.

Thanks Guys.

[ants]

i can see a lot of people offloading papley and bennedy next week if they both get dud scores this week! there BE will increase dramatically!

[Money Shot]

Is Dunkley any chance of returning to the Bulldogs line up.  Does anyone know how he went in the VFL.

With Murphy out he could be a chance! Didn't really do much in the first few weeks though.
He is my team so I hope he does but it's more than likely he won't.

[RaisyDaisy]

Is Dunkley any chance of returning to the Bulldogs line up.  Does anyone know how he went in the VFL.

With Murphy out he could be a chance! Didn't really do much in the first few weeks though.
He is my team so I hope he does but it's more than likely he won't.

Wood comes in for Bob

Jong took Dunkleys spot

[RaisyDaisy]

Plowman and Sumner named to play this week

Could be some much needed downgraded options - hopefully they go ok

[frenzy]

no pertracca this week. have to wait another week for him

Rnd 7 or 8 bubble boy, looking good. :)

[jeesh]

Hewett or Crouch to Callum Ah Chee worth a trade? I'm thinking his JS might be alright seeing he missed round 3 due to illness apparently and has come straight back in to take Matera's spot.

[sammy123]

Hewett or Crouch to Callum Ah Chee worth a trade? I'm thinking his JS might be alright seeing he missed round 3 due to illness apparently and has come straight back in to take Matera's spot.

ah chee hasn't scored that well from memory

[sammy123]

petracca had another 32 disposals and 1 goal on weekend