Rookie discussions and when to cash

[sammy123]

What are peoples thoughts on Mills?

Scoring is underwhelming for someone who is 211k

Everyone is talking about dropping Gresham etc but he sits on the bench while Mills is on field scoring

I never really wanted him but was more or less forced to. Thinking of dumping him

mills is still scoring okay. gresham will probably b dropped this week

[Mat0369]

I don't have Gresham so I am trying to figure out who becomes Paps.

[RoughRed]

What are peoples thoughts on Mills?

Scoring is underwhelming for someone who is 211k

Everyone is talking about dropping Gresham etc but he sits on the bench while Mills is on field scoring

I never really wanted him but was more or less forced to. Thinking of dumping him

Agree Gresham would go before Mills and the other rookie that is giving me some concern is Dunkley.

He scored 71 and 68 which is good enough on field as a rookie and has rock solid JS

Gresh 44 and 37 and could be dropped.

I will definitely be keeping Mills. The only rookie I am considering trading in my side TBH is Gresham. The rest of the rookies in my side are going well enough to make some decent coin.

+2

[MC]

What are peoples thoughts on Mills?

Scoring is underwhelming for someone who is 211k

Everyone is talking about dropping Gresham etc but he sits on the bench while Mills is on field scoring

I never really wanted him but was more or less forced to. Thinking of dumping him

Agree Gresham would go before Mills and the other rookie that is giving me some concern is Dunkley.

He scored 71 and 68 which is good enough on field as a rookie and has rock solid JS

Gresh 44 and 37 and could be dropped.

I will definitely be keeping Mills. The only rookie I am considering trading in my side TBH is Gresham. The rest of the rookies in my side are going well enough to make some decent coin.

+2

Agree.

[Judd Magic]

Does everyone think that Papley is safe enough to start on the ground if I downgrade Barlow to him?  :-\

Other forwards are Hall, B.Kennedy, S.Gray, Wells, Kerridge (McCarthy, Petracca) Menadue on mid bench to swing with Petrecca.

Would use the extra cash to either go Rockcliff > R.Gray or Oliver > R.Gray depending if Rockcliff misses or not.

[RaisyDaisy]

Does everyone think that Papley is safe enough to start on the ground if I downgrade Barlow to him?  :-\

Other forwards are Hall, B.Kennedy, S.Gray, Wells, Kerridge (McCarthy, Petracca) Menadue on mid bench to swing with Petrecca.

Would use the extra cash to either go Rockcliff > R.Gray or Oliver > R.Gray depending if Rockcliff misses or not.

At this early stage of the year, Papley at F6 is absolutely fine

[Judd Magic]

Does everyone think that Papley is safe enough to start on the ground if I downgrade Barlow to him?  :-\

Other forwards are Hall, B.Kennedy, S.Gray, Wells, Kerridge (McCarthy, Petracca) Menadue on mid bench to swing with Petrecca.

Would use the extra cash to either go Rockcliff > R.Gray or Oliver > R.Gray depending if Rockcliff misses or not.

At this early stage of the year, Papley at F6 is absolutely fine

Cheers RD.  8)

[billnats]

I'm stuck between Rocky for Gray... or holding Rocky and just doing Gresham to Parish.
Parish should be able to cut it until Rocky is back and firing.

Feels way too sideways either way  ???

[eaglesman]

Mitch McGovern job security?

[RoughRed]

Mitch McGovern job security?

Should be ok this week.... winners are grinners  ;D
Not sure long term ... seems to be doing a job that they need, quick at ground level, plays above his height
Any comment from the crows camp out there?

[TomK]

Mitch McGovern job security?

He will play this week at the least. He has certainly proved me wrong, impressed me quite a bit. Our depth is very good at the moment so will always be under pressure to perform to keep his spot. He adds another dimension to our forward line with his athleticism so I'm a big fan of him staying in the team but Cameron is too good for the SANFL and will be back in the AFL sooner rather than later, probably at the expense of Gov.

[sammy123]

I'm stuck between Rocky for Gray... or holding Rocky and just doing Gresham to Parish.
Parish should be able to cut it until Rocky is back and firing.

Feels way too sideways either way  ???

gresham may go this week

[RaisyDaisy]

I think Gresham is the rookie to make way this week for corrective rookie trades

If he keeps scoring 40's he will be such a slow burn and take forever to make cash whilst not providing great cover

Even if he is named, I think he is gone for Papley for mine

[sammy123]

I think Gresham is the rookie to make way this week for corrective rookie trades

If he keeps scoring 40's he will be such a slow burn and take forever to make cash whilst not providing great cover

Even if he is named, I think he is gone for Papley for mine

well said RD. i agree

[GoLions]

I think Gresham is the rookie to make way this week for corrective rookie trades

If he keeps scoring 40's he will be such a slow burn and take forever to make cash whilst not providing great cover

Even if he is named, I think he is gone for Papley for mine

And if you don't have Gresh? :P